Face Off: Should Hong Kong permanently switch to using drone shows instead of fireworks for special occasions?

With advances in technology, drone shows have become increasingly popular. As environmental concerns are growing, the shift to using drone shows instead of fireworks has become a necessity for Hong Kong.

While fireworks may spur temporary enjoyment in spectators, they do not outweigh the harm caused by chemicals dispersing into the air. Fireworks release sulphur dioxide, carbon dioxide, carbon monoxide, and particulate matter, all of which are detrimental to the environment.

China’s fireworks ban sparks fiery debate ahead of Lunar New Year

Drone shows, however, are more environmentally friendly and can lower carbon emissions. Because drones operate on electric batteries, they offer a pollution-free alternative to traditional fireworks. Such reductions in emissions improve air quality, thus lessening the possibility of respiratory diseases.

Moreover, drone shows provide a mesmerising and unique experience. Cutting-edge technology allows synchronised choreography, where the drones display images by arranging themselves into various aerial movements and formations. The drones can dance, twirl, and move in perfect harmony, creating a breathtaking spectacle to captivate audiences.

Drone shows are also highly cost-effective. While some may argue that these shows may have a more significant upfront cost per drone than fireworks, the overall cost can be cheaper when taking into account the show’s intricacy and ongoing maintenance.

Drones can be programmed to conduct complex and coordinated motions, minimising the need for physical work and lowering the danger of accidents or errors. Additionally, drones can be reused multiple times, whereas fireworks have to be repurchased, making them more cost-effective in the long term.

Taking all of the above into account, it is apparent that drone shows are in the city’s best interest. Fireworks not only pollute the environment but are far more dangerous.

Hence, because of these main factors – protecting the environment, utilising technology and reducing cost – Hong Kong should shift to using drone shows instead of fireworks for special occasions.

Hong Kong’s tradition of using fireworks is vital to its tourism and economic development. It would diminish if fireworks ceased to light up the city during huge festivals like Christmas, New Year’s Eve and National Day.

Shifting the use of fireworks to drone shows would damage the cultural spirit of our homeland.

Fireworks have a unique allure that cannot be replaced by drones. The booming sound of an explosion adds a distinct excitement while drones remain primarily quiet. The visual spectacle of bright, colourful explosions in the sky is something that drone shows, limited by orientation purposes, cannot currently achieve. The auditory and visual aspects of fireworks are what make special occasions in Hong Kong thrilling.

Explainer: What to know about Fourth of July holiday origins and traditions

Fireworks bring Hongkongers together, reinforce social bonds and instil a sense of cultural identity. They have been part of Hong Kong’s fabric for over 40 years, and preserving the tradition allows us to learn from history and appreciate the progress made by previous generations. Undeniably, fireworks breathe life into Hong Kong.

Fireworks are instrumental in shaping the culture of Hong Kong, showcasing the region’s dynamism and vibrancy. This attracts tourists, ultimately boosting the economy and establishing the region as an attractive global hub.

While some argue that drone shows are more environmentally friendly, it is important to note the negative impact they can have on the environment. For instance, drones flying low or in sensitive areas can cause habitat destruction, especially in locations with fragile ecosystems or nesting sites. Nesting birds, marine mammals and other wildlife may be driven away from their habitats because of the presence of drones.

Green fireworks, designed to minimise their impact on the environment, already exist. These fireworks employ alternative materials and technologies to reduce air and water pollution, noise, and waste. They strike a balance between tradition and environmental awareness.

Fireworks are an irreplaceable tradition in Hong Kong, and they must be celebrated and preserved by incorporating environmentally friendly practices.