US President Trump continues to threaten defiant Harvard University

Published: 
Listen to this article

Trump said the institution should lose its tax-exempt status after failing to change how it runs, selects student

Agence France-Presse |
Published: 
Comment

Latest Articles

ICE raids: Trump orders mass deportation in Democratic cities, curfew lifted in protest-hit LA

Israel and Iran trade fire for fifth day, Trump leaves G7 summit

Hong Kong urged to ban cruel ear cropping after Doberman puppy death

Former JYP USA girl group member sues label, alleges abuse and exploitation

Why your pee’s colour and smell matter more than you think

Hong Kong named third most Muslim-friendly non-Islamic travel hotspot

A view of Harvard University’s business school campus in Cambridge, Massachusetts, US. Photo: Reuters

United States president Donald Trump has ramped up his conflict with elite higher-education institutions in the country, threatening to strip Harvard University’s tax-exempt status.

This escalation in what some are calling a war against educational establishments comes as Harvard refused to submit to wide-ranging government surveillance.

Harvard, an Ivy League university that is perhaps the country’s most famous educational institution, stands out for defying Trump.

In contrast, several other universities and a string of powerful law firms have folded under intense pressure from the White House in its crackdown on American institutions.

Harvard’s president, Alan Garber, said the school would not “negotiate over its independence or its constitutional rights”.

President Trump signs order to ‘eliminate’ the US Education Department

Tuesday’s threat of a major tax bill comes a day after the freezing of US$2.2 billion (HK$17.07 billion) in federal funding.

The effects are already being felt on a campus that has produced 162 Nobel Prize winners and whose alums range from Facebook co-founder Mark Zuckerberg to eight US presidents.

The university said one faculty member had just been told to halt her tuberculosis research because of “the broader funding freeze”.

But the mood was defiant.

“I love it. I think it’s amazing. I think more schools across the country need to. It shows that you’re not going to bow down, you’re not going to let free speech be taken,” student Darious Hanson told Agence France-Presse.

A demonstrator stands in front of the statue of John Harvard – the first major benefactor of Harvard College – draped in the Palestinian flag at a student encampment protesting against the war in Gaza in April 2024. Photo: AP

Trump posted on social media that non-profit Harvard “should lose its Tax Exempt Status and be Taxed as a Political Entity” if the university does not submit to his demands to change how it runs, including selection of students and authority for professors.

Trump and his White House team have justified their pressure campaign on universities as a reaction to what they say is uncontrolled antisemitism and support for the Palestinian political group Hamas.

Trump “wants to see Harvard apologise. And Harvard should apologise,” Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt told journalists.

The antisemitism allegations are based on demonstrations that swept across campuses last year, which protested the war in Gaza and US support of Israel.

Columbia University in New York – an epicentre of the protests – stood down last month and agreed to oversight of its Middle Eastern department after being threatened with a loss of US$400 million (HK$3.1 billion) in federal funds.

The Lens: Trump’s executive orders on DEI spark major lawsuit

The White House has also strong-armed dozens of universities over policies meant to encourage racial diversity among students and staff by threatening to remove federal funding.

The White House has cited similarly ideological goals in its unprecedented crackdown on law firms, pressuring them to volunteer hundreds of millions of dollars worth of legal work to support issues that Trump supports.

Harvard, the oldest and wealthiest university in the United States, is now the most prominent institution to resist Trump’s ever-growing bid for control.

The Trump administration is demanding that a wide range of Harvard departments come under outside supervision for potential antisemitism. It also seeks to require “viewpoint diversity” in student admissions and choice of professors.

Garber’s insistence that Harvard cannot “allow itself to be taken over by the federal government” sets up a likely long-running, high-profile fight.

Harvard University stands defiant, refusing to give in to demands of management and surveillance from the country’s president. Photo: Reuters

Hardline presidential advisers such as Stephen Miller depict universities as bastions of anticonservative forces that need to be brought to heel – a message that resonates strongly with Trump’s hard-right anti-elite base.

For Trump’s opponents, Harvard’s refusal to bend marks a chance to draw a line in the sand against an authoritarian takeover.

“Harvard has set an example for other higher-ed institutions – rejecting an unlawful and ham-fisted attempt to stifle academic freedom,” former president Barack Obama wrote on X. “Let’s hope other institutions follow suit.”

Dozens of universities and other stakeholders are separately battling the Trump administration in court over broad research funding cuts that have led to staff lay-offs and created deep uncertainty among US academics.

Sign up for the YP Teachers Newsletter
Get updates for teachers sent directly to your inbox
By registering, you agree to our T&C and Privacy Policy
Comment