Advertisement
Diplomacy
ChinaDiplomacy

Western framework ‘cannot explain’ China, academics say in call for context

Chinese politics, progress and governance cannot be fully explained by existing theories but are ‘demonstrably effective’, conference hears

Reading Time:2 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
14
The World Conference on China Studies, which opened in Shanghai on Tuesday, comes as Beijing advocates respect for the equality and diversity of civilisations. Photo: Xinhua
Vanessa Caiin Shanghai

Western theoretical frameworks are often ill-suited for China studies, according to Chinese academics who called instead for research that was grounded in the country’s specific context.

The case for a tailored approach, bolstered by field research to correct biases and enable deeper understanding, was made at this week’s World Conference on China Studies in Shanghai, attended by hundreds of Chinese and foreign academics.

Amid an intense war of narratives with the United States, China has been making an effort to build soft power with the argument that its development path offers an alternative to the Western approach.
Advertisement
Beijing has also been promoting the Global Civilisation Initiative, proposed by President Xi Jinping in March 2023, which advocates respect for the equality and diversity of civilisations and opposes any country imposing its values on another.

07:23

Xi Jinping urges SCO summit members’ cooperation and the setting up of a development bank

Xi Jinping urges SCO summit members’ cooperation and the setting up of a development bank

At the forum’s opening ceremony on Tuesday, Lin Shangli, president of Renmin University of China, said it was hard to interpret the transformation of non-Western countries from ancient to modern civilisations through Western logic and knowledge systems.

Advertisement

“Clearly, Western logic cannot explain [China] and we must return to the Chinese context itself to do so,” Lin said, giving the example of China’s governance structure, which could not be explained by Western theory because of the huge gap in social scale.

SCMP Series
[ 4 of 12 ]
Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x