appConfigEntityId

bodyType

customContents

entityId

entityUuid

isVideo

articlePageQuery

article

articleSchemaContent

content

hooksArticlePageAdvertisementConfigArticle

hooksArticlePageFloatingButtonConfigArticle

appConfig

filter

json

liveArticle

Letters

India has shown the world that universal suffrage is not suitable for a country with huge population. India’s 2019 election lasted six weeks and political parties spent US$8 billion, an average of US$8 per voter, while 60 per cent of its population makes just US$3 a day.
After 70 years of Western-style democracy in India, some Indian scholars say Western values do not suit the ancient Eastern civilisation. If India, which was colonised and Westernised by Britain for some 200 years, is finding that Western values are not a good fit, imagine how these would fit China.
No one system suits all. Surely we Chinese have the wisdom to develop a political system that suits our civilisation.
China today is the second-largest economy and has the third-strongest armed military in the world. Except for the United States, no democratic country can boast China’s accomplishments. The US did not build a high speed rail network in just over a decade like China did.
Democracy is not a very efficient system. China needs a highly efficient system to quickly improve the livelihood of its population, lift more people into the middle class and match the military capabilities of the US and Russia.
China’s current system is strengthening the country. One day, China may add freedom of speech. When the easterly wind is stronger than westerly wind, like during the Tang dynasty, China will open up completely.

 
Whether due to its population or need for efficiency, democracy means self-destruction for China. Therefore, when working towards universal suffrage, Hongkongers must accept Article 23 of the Basic Law to show loyalty to the central government.
If you were the boss, would you hire people who oppose you? Do not say Hong Kong’s chief executive is a “running dog” of the central government. Employees tend to follow the lead of their bosses. At least this boss, the central government, is one of us and is working for the good of our country, not a foreign ruler invested in another country at our expense.
P.Y. Chan, Ontario, Canada
 


Tung Chee-hwa’s rise to first Hong Kong chief executive and elder statesman

True friends stab you in the front? The importance of debate in today’s world

Stop mourning Hong Kong. It’s evolving, not dying

Court approves last attempt by 11 jailed opposition figures to clear their names

Hong Kong Basic Law

Why China has no use for democracy: India has shown the pitfalls of Western values

An Indian woman stands in front of a mural depicting a scene from the Hindu epic Mahabharata, as she displays an indelible ink mark on her finger, proof of having cast her vote in national elections, on May 12, 2019, in Prayagraj in the northern state of Uttar Pradesh. Photo: AP

Hong Kong risks putting autonomy at risk with challenges to Beijing’s authority

A float featuring the “one country, two systems” principle travels past Tiananmen Square in Beijing during a parade marking the 70th anniversary of the founding of the People’s Republic of China, on National Day, October 1. Photo: CNS via Reuters

Hong Kong protests have their roots in China’s hardline policies under Xi Jinping

Protesters hang up a banner during a march in Hong Kong on October 20. Photo: Reuters

How China and India shaped global civilisation, well before the West arrived

India’s ancient practices of yoga and meditation are an integral part of the modern concepts of wellness and mindfulness. Photo: The Dawn