appConfigEntityId

bodyType

customContents

entityId

entityUuid

isVideo

articlePageQuery

article

articleSchemaContent

content

hooksArticlePageAdvertisementConfigArticle

hooksArticlePageFloatingButtonConfigArticle

appConfig

filter

json

liveArticle

Kunal Purohit

“What is going on with Nepal? Have the Chinese completely taken over?”
On July 9, an Indian television anchor launched into a tirade with those words, at the opening of a 15-minute prime-time debate, tagged “China Bullies Nepal”.
Debates like these are common in the Indian television news industry, as are incendiary hashtags, lengthy tirades and screaming matches. The target of many of them over the past month-and-a-half has been Nepal.
The role of Indian television news channels has grown increasingly prominent in the rising friction between New Delhi and Kathmandu in recent weeks. Last week, the Nepal Cable TV Association said it would ban some Indian channels after they carried unsubstantiated stories alleging a romantic link-up between Nepal Prime Minister KP Sharma Oli and the Chinese ambassador Hou Yanqi.

In one report by Zee Hindustan, the reason for fraying Nepal-India ties was that Oli had “given his heart away and … found himself in a Chinese honey trap that forced him to bargain with India-Nepal ties”. The report, which has since been deleted from its YouTube channel, called Hou a “Chinese spy” and a “poison maiden”, and made allegations about Oli and Hou without providing any evidence.
Another channel, India News, on July 6 carried a report titled, “How Oli was trapped by China’s honey trap”, and alleged that Hou had used “cunning and style to fulfil Xi’s desire to break India’s friendship with Nepal”.
The unsubstantiated claims prompted an angry Nepal government to lodge a protest with India and send a diplomatic note asking it to “take steps against [the broadcast of] fake, baseless and insensitive as well as abusive” stories.
“The ill-intentioned smear campaign unleashed by a section of Indian media has deeply hurt the feelings of Nepali people and persona of Nepali leadership,” the note said.
Amid stand-off with China, India faces new low in bilateral ties with Nepal
Taking their cue, Nepal’s cable operators said they were blocking a handful of Indian news channels to show their “patriotism”.
Analysts on both sides of the Himalayan border said this had raised questions over whether the Narendra Modi government has been orchestrating adverse media coverage to counter Nepal in an ongoing territorial dispute between the two countries.
REPEATED TARGETING
The Indian TV news industry has been routinely criticised for its hypernationalism – anchors have dressed up in military fatigues and held toy guns while discussing military skirmishes with Pakistan.
In the last two months, its attention has turned towards Nepal. Tensions between the two countries have been running high since Nepal objected to India inaugurating a new road in a disputed border territory in early May.
When the objections were dismissed by the Modi government, the Oli government responded by approving a new territorial map that included areas claimed by both India and Nepal.
However, while Oli has taken potshots at India throughout the crisis – from calling the coronavirus an “Indian virus” to mocking its emblem – it is the Indian media that has been doing all the talking in the opposite direction.

On June 13, the day Nepal’s lower house of Parliament approved the map, an Indian news channel called Nepal the “latest victim” of “China’s thuggery”.
Referring to the Oli government’s move to appoint a panel to gather facts and documents to back Nepal’s claim, the Indian news report was disparaging of the move and said: “Nepal just realised that it will have to show documents to prove its claim on territories. But, the truth is, it doesn’t have any.”
On July 3, a popular Hindi television channel, Republic Bharat, alleged Oli’s “love” for China was going to prove “costly for Nepal”, and concluded that “Nepal’s people and opposition parties are in no mood to tolerate Oli”.
On July 4, the same channel called Nepal, Pakistan and China “demonic triplets” and said Nepal was “China’s puppet”. It added that Nepal-China ties were an “unholy friendship”.
China on their mind: why the India-Nepal border has become a global flashpoint
Sudhir Chaudhary, the editor-in-chief of Zee News, a private channel founded by Subhash Chandra (a parliamentarian backed by Modi’s ruling Bharatiya Janata Party party), last week blamed China for the cable operators’ decision to ban Indian channels.
“As we have said, these days, all of Nepal’s decisions are taken by China. Even this decision has surely been suggested by China,” Chaudhary said, adding that Nepal was “scared” of Indian journalists and media who were “exposing” them to the world.
This kind of aggressive coverage is seen as an extension of the Indian government’s foreign policy
Deepak Adhikari, independent Nepali journalist
Deepak Adhikari, an independent journalist based out of Kathmandu, said statements like these had “rankled” Nepalis.
“There has been a constant targeting of Nepal in the Indian media, which has been very unfortunate,” he said. “We [are used to seeing] the Indian media targeting Pakistan, but now, they seem to have zeroed in on us.”
Ujjwal Prajapati, a researcher at the Centre for Media Research in Kathmandu, said coverage had crossed a line when Zee News aired the claims about Oli and Hou – a story that was “totally dramatised, defamatory, abusive [and not based in] fact”, he said.
“The general tendency of Indian news channels that have been blocked in Nepal is that they are engaged in disseminating hate, and do not understand the sensitivity of the issues that they are reporting,” Prajapati said.

ANIMOSITY LINGERS
Animosity between Nepalis and the Indian media has been lingering for years.
Shortly after the 2015 Nepal earthquake, which killed nearly 9,000 people, anger erupted towards the Indian television crews who had gone to Nepal to cover the story. Much of their coverage focused on India’s aid efforts and for days, the hashtag “Go Back Indian Media” trended on Twitter.
Regarding the most recent bust-up, the Chinese ambassador to India, Sun Weidong, last week said media from both countries must “avoid inciting antagonism”.
Adhikari said many in Kathmandu believed New Delhi had orchestrated the recent coverage.
“There is a sense here that the Indian media has capitulated before the establishment,” he said. “Hence, this kind of aggressive coverage is seen as an extension of the Indian government’s foreign policy. Since it can’t take on China, Pakistan is the punching bag for the Indian media, and Nepal is the soft target.”
China-Nepal Railway: debt trap, godsend, threat to India, or just a pie in the sky?
Prajapati, the media researcher, pointed to how the reports broadcast by Indian TV news channels were “in line” with the Indian government’s stance. This reflected “the relationship between the media and Indian establishment”, he said.
The former head of Amnesty India, Aakar Patel, said the Modi government maintained tight control over the Indian media’s coverage.
“There is no question that the Modi government uses the media as an extension of its foreign policy. News channels receive instructions on a daily basis from Modi’s office on what it should be covering and how,” he said.
Patel, a senior journalist who has helmed various newsrooms in India, said such control was difficult to resist, pointing to the industry’s dynamics. Estimates show India has more than 400 news channels, reaching some 400 million viewers. “The Indian government is the biggest advertiser in the country, so in a competitive media space like India, it can be very tough to refuse to listen to the government.”
Can India afford an economic battle with China?
The coverage was having a serious effect on the ties between the two countries and Indian news channels and policymakers had not understood this, said Kanak Mani Dixit, the founder of Himal SouthAsian magazine.
“Rather than think of this as something that demeans the Nepali nation-state, have Indian policymakers sat back and thought: ‘Does this also hurt our relationship with China, because we are not only targeting the prime minister of Nepal, but the formal representative of Beijing in Kathmandu?,” Dixit said in an interview to the J-Pod podcast on Monday.
Patel said neither the media nor the government were likely to change tack soon. He said Modi and the BJP were focused on controlling the narrative domestically. “They will do whatever it takes to ensure that their image stays intact.”



The cooling trap: how Asia’s air conditioners are making heatwaves worse

Reporter’s note: two Delhis, one weekend – when the world came to dinner

Anwar was on song in India. Will Malaysia reap the rewards?

What Hong Kong cinema can take away from a popular Chinese war film

India

Is New Delhi using Indian media to attack Nepal as it grows closer to China?

Prime Minister of Nepal KP Sharma Oli and Chinese ambassador Hou Yanqi. Photo: NurPhoto

Chinese Ambassador to Nepal Hou Yanqi. HANDOUT PHOTO

Nepalese rescue members gather at the collapsed Dharahara Tower in Kathmandu on April 25, 2015. A powerful 7.9 magnitude earthquake struck Nepal, causing massive damage in the capital Kathmandu with strong tremors felt across neighbouring countries. AFP PHOTO / PRAKASH MATHEMA (Photo by PRAKASH MATHEMA / AFP)

Newly appointed Ambassador of the People's Republic of China, Hou Yanqi shakes hand with Prime Minister KP Sharma Oli. Photo: MoFA

Can India afford an economic battle with China?

Indian protesters burn an effigy of Chinese President Xi Jinping in Kolkata. Photo: AFP

In this Oct. 16, 2016, file photo, Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi, front and Chinese President Xi Jinping shake hands with leaders at the BRICS summit in Goa, India. At least three Indian soldiers, including a senior army officer, have been killed in a confrontation with Chinese soldiers along their disputed frontier high in the Himalayas where thousands of troops on both sides have been facing off for over a month, the Indian army said. The army said in a statement Tuesday, June 16, 2020, that a “violent faceoff” took place in Galwan valley in the Ladakh region on Monday night “with casualties on both sides.” (AP Photo/Manish Swarup, File)

TOPSHOT - Indian soldiers walk at the foothills of a mountain range near Leh on June 23, 2020. - India's Prime Minister Narendra Modi said on June 19 that his country was "hurt and angry" after a border clash with China that left 20 troops dead, and warned that the army has been given free reign to respond to any new violence. (Photo by Tauseef MUSTAFA / AFP)

An Indian army convoy moves on the Srinagar- Ladakh highway at Gagangeer, northeast of Srinagar, India, Wednesday, June 17, 2020. Indian security forces said neither side fired any shots in the clash in the Ladakh region Monday that was the first deadly confrontation on the disputed border between India and China since 1975. China said Wednesday that it is seeking a peaceful resolution to its Himalayan border dispute with India following the death of 20 Indian soldiers in the most violent confrontation in decades. (AP Photo/Mukhtar Khan)

Amid stand-off with China, India faces new low in bilateral ties with Nepal

A Nepali activist burns an image of Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi during a May protest against India’s unilateral construction of a link road that passes through some territories also claimed by Nepal. Photo: EPA

18 June 2020, India, Ganderbal: A soldier of the Indian Border Security Force (BSF) guards a national highway leading to Ladakh region. India and China are engaging in a dialogue to cool down the situation in the border area where violent clashes between Indian and Chinese soldiers took place on Monday night in the disputed Galwan Valley. Photo: Idrees Abbas/SOPA Images via ZUMA Wire/dpa

China India Nepal Pakistan Border disputes in the Western Himalayas

People light candles on an outline of the new map of Nepal drawn on a road as they celebrate the approval of the political map to include territory claimed by both India and Nepal, in Kathmandu, Nepal, Saturday, June 13, 2020. Nepal’s Parliament on Saturday overwhelmingly approved the constitutional amendment to change the nation’s political map. The voting follows the government's issuing of a new map last month that showed the disputed territory within its borders. (AP Photo/Niranjan Shrestha)

Nepal’s start-up scene is thriving, but China and India have yet to notice

Tootle is a ride-sharing app in Nepal. Photo: Handout/Tootle

Katmandu, Nepal Thamel is a commercial neighbourhood in Kathmandu, the capital of Nepal. Thamel has been the centre of the tourist industry in Kathmandu [11FEBRUARY2018 TRAVEL POST MAGAZINE]

In this picture taken on October 26, 2018, a Nepali-made robot waiter picks up food from the kitchen to bring to customers at Naulo restaurant in Kathmandu. - "Please enjoy your meal," says Nepal's first robot waiter, Ginger, as she delivers a plate of steaming dumplings to a table of hungry customers. The poor Himalayan nation is better known for its soaring mountain peaks than technological prowess, but a group of self-taught young innovators are seeking to change that. (Photo by Prakash MATHEMA / AFP) / TO GO WITH Nepal-technology-lifestyle-robot, PHOTOESSAY

Traffic moves along a road in Kathmandu, Nepal, on Wednesday, Nov. 1, 2017. India and China have often jostled for influence in Nepal, a nation of 28 million people sandwiched between the two Asian giants. While Chinese investment in Nepal has surpassed India, the practical difficulties of transporting people and goods across the world's highest mountains have always pushed Nepal toward India, its largest trading partner. Photographer: Sara Hylton/Bloomberg

A rural internet entrepreneur, and his team, is now setting his sites on bringing WiFi to Manaslu to benefit schools and clinics of the area. The crux of the project is a relay station high above the Budi Gandaki valley close to the entrance to Tsum Valley Photo credit: Retailnewsasia.com

KATHMANDU, NEPAL - APRIL 28: A view from an adjacent rooftop shows the destruction left by the April 25 earthquake of Inachok, an area of Bhaktapur on April 28, 2015 in Bhaktapur, Nepal.

A man wears a mask as a preventive measure against the coronavirus outbreak, in Kathmandu, Nepal February 16, 2020. REUTERS/Soe Zeya Tun

Nepal lawmakers endorse map including area disputed with India

Nepal’s Foreign Minister Pradeep Gyawali. Photo: AP

China on their mind: why the India-Nepal border has become a global flashpoint

A Nepalese activist burns an image of Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi during a protest in Kathmandu, Nepal. Photo: EPA

Police detain demonstrators during a protest against India's newly inaugurated link road to the Chinese border, in front of the Parliament in Kathmandu on May 10, 2020. - Nepal protested India's inauguration of a new road to China that passes through territory claimed by Kathmandu on May 9, with police arresting dozens demonstrating close to India's embassy. (Photo by STR / AFP)

Nepal's new territorial map, released earlier this week, has shown the area in the light red shade to be part of its territory, evoking strong reactions from India. This came after India, in its new maps released in November last year, showed the Kalapani area (marked in deep red) to be part of its territory.

epa08395809 An Indian youth wearing a face mask stands in front of a poster of Indian prime minister Narendra Modi during a nationwide lockdown in Bangalore, India, 01 May 2020. The country's initial 21-day lockdown that was implemented due to the ongoing pandemic of the COVID-19 disease caused by the SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus was extended until 03 May 2020, reports state. EPA-EFE/JAGADEESH NV

Police detain demonstrators during a protest against India's newly inaugurated link road to the Chinese border, in Kathmandu on May 10, 2020. - Nepal protested India's inauguration of a new road to China that passes through territory claimed by Kathmandu on May 9, with police arresting dozens demonstrating close to India's embassy. (Photo by PRAKASH MATHEMA / AFP)

This Week in Asia

Politics

News

Asia

South Asia

China

Diplomacy


Indian TV news channels have recently targeted Nepal, including alleging that its leader KP Sharma Oli was ‘honey-trapped’ by ‘poison maiden’ Chinese ambassador Hou Yanqi
Kathmandu has filed a diplomatic protest asking the Modi government to take steps against the ‘smear campaign’



Unsubstantiated stories in Indian media alleging romance between KP Sharma Oli and Hou Yanqi as the cause of fraying India-Nepal ties have prompted a diplomatic protest from Kathmandu.


Nepal

China-India relations

Nepal earthquake 2015