Advertisement
Singapore
This Week in AsiaOpinion

OpinionSingapore’s blueprint for economic success: plan, but be prepared to adapt

External shocks and changing domestic conditions often render plans unfeasible, so being agile is a better policy

5-MIN READ5-MIN
1
Listen
A city view of Singapore on Tuesday. About 80 per cent of Singaporeans live in public housing. Photo: Xinhua
Donald Low
In the discussion on Hong Kong’s first ever five-year plan, much ink has been spilled on the merits of a planned economy. The most recent example of this was Anthony Rowley’s commentary that cited Singapore as an example of a highly successful planned economy.
Unfortunately, he misrepresents what planning in Singapore is about. There are lessons that Hong Kong can draw from how the Singapore government navigated a changing environment – but not the ones Rowley highlights.

It is quite understandable why an observer would view Singapore as a planned economy. After all, signs of order are all around. Nearly 80 per cent of Singaporeans live in public housing; the city is well-designed, green, and manicured. Clearly, this is a city that has been meticulously planned and engineered for decades.

Above all, Singapore’s politics is carefully managed by a ruling party that has been in power since 1959, and political dissent is often constrained by a paternalistic state.

People view a light projection as part of a preview of the Singapore Night Festival in Singapore, on August 19. Photo: Xinhua
People view a light projection as part of a preview of the Singapore Night Festival in Singapore, on August 19. Photo: Xinhua

But the idea of the Singapore economy as a top-down, dirigiste and planned one is a caricature at best. While various government agencies in Singapore engage in planning (loosely defined), the city state has never had five or 10-year plans, nor set production targets the way the Eastern bloc countries and China did.

Policies, not plans

Advertisement
Select Voice
Select Speed
1.00x