-
Advertisement
Asean
This Week in AsiaOpinion
Sharon Seah

Asian Angle | How Asean can resolve its Myanmar dilemma post-election

Asean should not discard the Five-Point Consensus, but translate it into a politically astute strategy of conditional engagement

Reading Time:4 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
1
Asean foreign ministers, including Philippine Foreign Secretary Theresa Lazaro (wearing gold) and Secretary General Kao Kim Hourn during the bloc’s Foreign Ministers’ Retreat in Cebu, the Philippines, on January 29. Photo: EPA/Handout
Derided by most international observers and the Myanmar diaspora as a sham, the recently concluded three-phase elections in Myanmar have entrenched military rule under a new constitutional government.
For Asean, the outcome throws into sharp relief an increasingly uncomfortable question: should it continue to marginalise the intransigent junta until it complies with the bloc’s Five-Point Consensus (5PC), or find a way to re-engage without betraying the Association of Southeast Asian Nations’ own norms?
After a retreat of Asean foreign ministers in late January, Philippine Foreign Secretary Theresa Lazaro, also the Asean chair’s special envoy on Myanmar, clarified that the ministers had not reached a consensus “as of now”.
Advertisement

The chair’s statement, while maintaining that “any meaningful political progress can only take place in an environment of peace, security and inclusivity, supported by the cessation of violence and inclusive dialogue”, masks strategic divergences within the bloc, because exactly how to achieve “meaningful political progress” remains the key unanswered question.

Vote counting takes place on January 25 in Yangon for Myanmar’s general election. Photo: Kyodo
Vote counting takes place on January 25 in Yangon for Myanmar’s general election. Photo: Kyodo

One camp is prepared to give some weight to the election outcome, however flawed, believing it is the start of a political transition, now framed as a generic transition rather than a “transition to democracy” – Asean’s lingo for Myanmar back in the 1990s. For these members, Myanmar could be welcomed back once there is a semblance of a stable government, however unrepresentative, allowing a return to “business as usual” with the country’s leaders rejoining Asean meetings.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Select Voice
Select Speed
1.00x