appConfigEntityId

bodyType

customContents

entityId

entityUuid

isVideo

articlePageQuery

article

articleSchemaContent

content

hooksArticlePageAdvertisementConfigArticle

hooksArticlePageFloatingButtonConfigArticle

appConfig

filter

json

liveArticle

Sam Beltran

The drowning of two university basketball players in the Philippines has raised concerns about the extreme training conditions and pressures surrounding student athletes in the country’s highly commercialised collegiate sports industry.
Incoming rookie player Rene Baterbonia, 19, and Nigerian student-athlete Divine Adili, 21, died on Monday during a school-sanctioned “team-building activity” in Dipaculao, Aurora, on the east coast of Luzon island.
Both played for the Blue Eagles of Ateneo de Manila University, one of the country’s most prestigious private schools and a powerhouse in the University Athletic Association of the Philippines (UAAP), the nation’s premier collegiate league.
The tragedy exposed how young players could be pushed into risky training environments as universities competed for prestige, alumni support and sporting success, former athletes, sports safety advocates and collegiate sports insiders said.
Police said on Monday that initial findings showed Baterbonia and Adili had been “carried by a strong current” while swimming in the open sea. A day later, they said there was no indication of foul play and described the deaths as a “natural accident”.
But as questions and speculation grew, Ateneo issued a fuller account three days after the drownings, saying the team had been “engaged in a conditioning exercise in knee-deep water near the shoreline when they were suddenly engulfed by massive waves and a powerful rip current”.
“While most of the players managed to fight their way back to safety, Rene and Divine were pulled away,” the university said, disputing rumours that ankle weights had been placed on the athletes during training.
The National Bureau of Investigation said it would launch a separate investigation into the deaths.

The official explanations have done little to quell public anger – particularly after Baterbonia’s mother demanded answers when she arrived in Manila from Agusan province in the southern Philippines to see her son’s body.
“They never informed me, ‘Ma’am, if your son joins us, he would be subjected to this kind of training and activities.’ If only they explained that to me, even if we are poor, I would not have allowed him to join,” she told reporters.
This Week in Asia has reached out to Baterbonia’s mother for comment.
Risk without safeguards
Beyond the immediate questions over what happened, the deaths have sharpened scrutiny of how far universities are expected to go in assessing risk, supervising off-campus activities and protecting athletes once they enter elite sports programmes.
“My reaction was one of disbelief,” Carlos*, an official in a rival UAAP university’s high-performance programme, said.
He said any reputable sports programme should weigh the risks of an activity against its purpose, and questioned what had happened in the planning stages.
“I’ve personally been pulled by a rip tide before, so I know what it feels like and how it can lead to something as tragic as this,” he said.
He believed that the Blue Eagles’ activity in Aurora was less about strength and conditioning than a boot camp to build camaraderie.
“The real goal of these activities is for the team to bond, to go through struggle together, and to come out stronger,” he said.
“But if it was me in that situation, I would have weighed the risk and decided against it. [Aurora] is known for its rough waters.”
After the drownings, accounts by former players resurfaced, in which they recounted being taken to a resort in Aurora for what they described as a “military-style camp”, including having phones confiscated, alarms blaring at 3am and swimming exercises in the sea.

Alumnus Mike Nieto recalled an incident in which an older teammate nearly drowned during a drill that involved swimming in the ocean.
“He’s supposed to run on the sand and then swim, but our veteran [player] didn’t know how to swim. Coach Tab [Baldwin] had to save him,” Nieto said.
On Friday, Baldwin said in a social media video that the Blue Eagles initially thought the players were in the shallows before realising they had been swept into much deeper water.
“I failed as a leader. I felt I had failed as a coach. I certainly felt like I had failed as a friend to Divine and Rene,” Baldwin said.
For some observers, the tragedy has raised questions not only about one training activity, but also about the rules and systems meant to protect student-athletes.
“Coaches employ different programmes, different strategies, and extreme training [that] are actually acceptable – but they should always come with caution,” said Bob*, a veteran sportscaster and lawyer.
“Endangering the lives of your players or any member of the team should be out of the question,” the avid supporter of another UAAP university team said.
“They could have taken precautions. They were doing this yearly,” he said, especially after former players had described earlier near-drowning incidents.

The incident showed the limits of the Student-Athletes Protection Act, intended to safeguard the welfare of student-athletes, said Kara Mallonga, a sports safety advocate and former official of the Philippines’ Games and Amusement Board.
Though the law restricted improper recruitment inducements and the treatment of student-athletes as commodities, it did not go far enough once they were inside a programme, she said.
“It covers recruitment and the preservation of amateur status, but doesn’t establish a statutory duty of care for training environments, require medical oversight during off-campus activities, mandate independent risk assessments, or provide protected channels for athletes to raise safety concerns,” she said.
Regardless of the outcome of the investigation, Bob argued that the university still bore responsibility.
“It’s a school-sanctioned activity – that alone already implicates them,” he said. “Even if the parents consented, they still have vicarious responsibility. So civilly, at the very least, it’s automatic.”
Price of winning
The question of athlete safeguards, insiders said, was inseparable from the growing commercialisation of UAAP sports, where school pride, alumni support and media exposure have raised the stakes.
“In major Philippine collegiate sporting environments, especially in revenue-generating sports like basketball and volleyball, the level of competition has risen to the point where it increasingly mirrors the professional arena,” Mallonga said.
Top schools invested heavily in recruitment, coaching and facilities, she said, with success tied to brand visibility and alumni engagement.
“When performance becomes a key metric, the pressure to sustain results moves through the organisation,” she said.
Insiders said the system needed to change before more lives were lost.
“There’s a lot of thought that has to go into deciding what to do in a programme. It’s not happening because there’s malice – I do believe this was an accident, and I wholly believe that there was no intention to put players at harm. But all accidents could have been prevented,” Carlos said.
* Names have been changed to protect identity


Hong Kong launching pilot scheme to bring in foreign carers for the elderly

Chinese research ship completes month-long mission near Scarborough Shoal

Should Beijing use its maritime militia as a backup force in the South China Sea?

South Korean killer’s drone escape from Philippine prison foiled by test footage

The Philippines

Drowning of student athletes in Philippines throws spotlight on collegiate sports industry

A candlelight service was held in honour of Rene Baterbonia and Divine Adili at Ateneo de Manila University’s chapel on Saturday. Photo: Facebook/ateneobasketball


The Blue Eagles is one of the top teams in the Philippines’ premier collegiate league. Photo: Facebook/ateneobasketball

Tab Baldwin, the Blue Eagles’ head coach. Photo: Facebook/ateneobasketball

In the basketball-crazy Philippines, top schools have invested heavily in recruitment, coaching and facilities. Photo: AFP

Why US and China are watching Philippines’ Marcos Jnr at Russia-Asean talks

Philippine President Ferdinand Marcos Jnr will head to Kazan from June 17 to 18 for the Asean-Russia Commemorative Summit. Photo: Pool via Reuters

Russia’s Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov (centre) arrives for the 19th East Asia Summit as part of the Asean summit in Vientiane, Laos, in 2024. Photo: EPA-EFE

An attendant at a petrol station in Quezon City on May 5. The Philippines is exploring ways to diversify fuel supplies and reduce its exposure to global price shocks. Photo: EPA

Hacking of Philippine Senate’s website spotlights widening political crisis

Armed Senate security personnel at the entrance of the Senate building in Manila on May 13 after gunshots were heard inside the Senate building. Photo: AFP

A screenshot of a message by the “Nullsec Philippines” hacktivist group in a social media post on Wednesday. Photo: Facebook/Nullsec Philippines

A screenshot of the Philippine Senate’s website when it was inaccessible, as seen on Thursday. Photo: Philippine Senate’s website

Philippine Senate president Alan Peter Cayetano meets the media at the Senate in Pasay City, Metro Manila, last month. Photo: EPA

Mindanao quake exposes Philippines’ vulnerability to ‘Big One’ tremor in Metro Manila

People collect their belongings from a damaged house following an earthquake off the southern Philippine island of Mindanao on Monday. Photo: Reuters

A damaged shop after a 7.8 magnitude earthquake, in General Santos City, Mindanao, the Philippines, on Monday. Photo: Xinhua

Children try to escape as the roof of a structure at Deped Mahayahay Elementary School collapses during an earthquake in Digos, Mindanao, on Monday. Photo: Deped Mahayahay Elementary School/Handout via Reuters

Patients sit at a school after being evacuated from a hospital following an earthquake off the southern Philippine island of Mindanao on Monday. Photo: Reuters

Vehicles damaged by debris after a powerful earthquake hit the Mindanao region in the Philippines on Monday. Photo: Ernesto Torres Jr via AP

Will Marcos’ shipbuilding push deliver lasting capacity for Philippines?

The West Cebu Industrial Park in Balamban town, Cebu, the Philippines. Photo: Handout

Philippine President Ferdinand Marcos Jnr and Japanese Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi shake hands before a summit meeting in Tokyo, Japan, on May 28. Photo: EPA

West Cebu Industrial Park is one of the Philippines’ key shipbuilding and heavy-industry hubs. Photo: Handout

A truck arrives at a container terminal in Navotas, Metro Manila. Shoring up the shipbuilding industry could also help strengthen the Philippines’ self-reliant defence posture, analysts say. Photo: Reuters

Philippine military chief assures no political intervention amid Senate turmoil

Philippine military chief Romeo Brawner Jnr. Photo: AFP

Philippine senators during a consultative meeting to investigate alleged anomalies in flood control projects, at the Senate in Pasay City, Metro Manila on Monday. Photo: EPA

The Philippine military has been urged by some figures to take sides in the bitter political feud between President Ferdinand Marcos Jnr and his deputy Sara Duterte-Carpio. Photo: Reuters

Philippine Senator Sherwin Gatchalian presides as Senate pro tempore during a plenary session at the Senate in Pasay, Metro Manila, on June 3. Photo: AFP

This Week in Asia

Health & Environment

News

Asia

Southeast Asia

The tragedy shows how young players could be pushed into risky training situations as universities compete for prestige, sports experts say


The tragedy shows how young players could be pushed into risky training situations as universities compete for prestige, sports experts say.


Athletes

Nigeria

Ateneo de Manila University (Philippines)

Drowning of student athletes in Philippines throws spotlight on collegiate sports industry

.css-1c6uqr6{color:inherit;font-weight:inherit;font-size:inherit;font-family:inherit;line-height:inherit;overflow-wrap:break-word;}The tragedy shows how young players could be pushed into risky training situations as universities compete for prestige, sports experts say

The tragedy shows how young players could be pushed into risky training situations as universities compete for prestige, sports experts say