Advertisement
Climate change
OpinionWorld Opinion
Paul Mottram

Opinion | 3 climate misconceptions that add to noise over energy and net zero

Confusion over power vs electricity, energy input vs output and net zero vs zero emission does not help the already complex climate conversation

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
2
The Datang Tuoketuo Power Plant in Inner Mongolia, with an installed capacity of 6720MW, is the world’s largest thermal power plant. Recognising the nuance of the debate on either side of the climate argument is essential to making continued progress. Photo: Handout

Reading recent media coverage about climate action means lurching between apparent victory and defeat. It’s triumph one day as another decarbonisation milestone is heralded. Then disaster the next as countries and companies alike walk back on climate commitments or veer perilously close to denying climate change altogether.

We can expect more such whiplash: Hong Kong Green Week takes place next month, the UN General Assembly and Climate Week NYC are also due to begin in September, followed by the Cop30 climate change summit in Brazil in November.

If the year so far is any guide, discourse at these events will be laced with three common misunderstandings (promoted deliberately or otherwise). They are simple and beguiling misconceptions that impede our understanding as an increasingly noisy debate rages.

Advertisement

The first is the tendency to conflate electricity with energy. The second: confusing energy input with energy output. And the third? Mistaking net-zero emissions for zero emissions.

This isn’t just splitting semantic hairs. In the race to decarbonise, headlines like “Renewables now supply 50 per cent of China’s power” frequently trumpet dramatic progress. They sound transformative – until you realise “power” usually means electricity, not total energy.

Advertisement

And therein lies a problem.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x