appConfigEntityId

bodyType

customContents

entityId

entityUuid

isVideo

articlePageQuery

article

articleSchemaContent

content

hooksArticlePageAdvertisementConfigArticle

hooksArticlePageFloatingButtonConfigArticle

appConfig

filter

json

liveArticle

Jane Lee

Why do some governments consistently turn long-term goals into visible results while others struggle to move beyond policy announcements? The answer often lies not in ideology and planning but in governance: the ability to identify priorities, coordinate action and sustain implementation.
As the Hong Kong government begins a public consultation on its first five-year plan, that question deserves careful attention.
The city is not short of ideas, research and innovative policy proposals. Yet some of its most stubborn challenges – housing, an ageing population, elderly care, urban renewal, talent shortages, social mobility and old-building management – have proved frustratingly persistent.
The challenge is not simply identifying problems. It is mustering the political will and building the capacity to overcome them.
Ultimately, citizens judge governments by the results they deliver. Can people find affordable, decent housing? Can young people see opportunities for upward mobility? Can businesses operate with confidence? Can communities feel their concerns being addressed? The legitimacy of any governing system rests on its ability to answer such questions.
This is why Hong Kong’s first five-year plan matters. It should go beyond a new planning cycle and policy document to become a mechanism for strengthening governance itself.


China’s transformation over the past four decades – from lifting hundreds of millions of people out of extreme poverty and dramatically improving air and water quality – was achieved not simply through ambitious goals and meticulous planning. It required all levels of government to align behind common objectives, mobilise resources on a vast scale, coordinate implementation and sustain effort over long periods of time. This is effective governance.
Hong Kong, by contrast, has long prided itself on efficiency. Yet efficiency alone does not guarantee effectiveness. The real test of governance is not how efficiently government actions are carried out but whether they solve the problems they were designed to address.
The five-year plan process illustrates this particularly well. Western observers might view the plan as a top-down directive issued by the central government. In reality, it is the culmination of a far broader governance process involving extensive policy research, expert consultation, local participation, review and adjustment. The published five-year plan is only the visible product of a much broader governance process informed by comprehensive bottom-up feedback.
Many of Hong Kong’s challenges are not isolated policy issues. They are interconnected structural problems. Housing affects social mobility and wealth distribution. An ageing population affects the healthcare system, welfare and public finances. Our success as a financial centre skews the supply and use of talent. Such issues cut across departmental boundaries and cannot be resolved through annual policy initiatives alone.
Too often, policies begin with clear intentions but lose momentum as they move through different layers of implementation. Responsibilities become fragmented, coordination weakens and outcomes fall short of expectations. The deadly Tai Po fire offers a textbook example.




Hong Kong’s executive-led system possesses significant strengths. It provides the executive branch of government with the authority to set policy goals, coordinate implementation across departments and allocate resources to pursue long-term objectives.
However, the power to issue instructions does not guarantee effective governance. A key purpose of a five-year plan should therefore be to bridge this gap – to turn authority into effectiveness, strategy into action and objectives into measurable results. Three priorities deserve particular attention.
First, Hong Kong should strengthen its capacity for long-term strategic policy research, such as on its future demographic structure. Governments perform best when they anticipate problems before they become crises.
Demographic change, labour force transformation, technological disruption and evolving economic competition all require planning horizons that extend beyond annual policy cycles. Strategic research should help the government identify emerging challenges early and map our long-range policy responses.
Second, Hong Kong should strengthen its multilayer mechanisms for social sensing and opinion gathering. Effective governance depends on a continuous exchange between policymakers and the communities they serve. Consultation should not be viewed as a procedural requirement but as an essential building block that informs policy design and implementation.
The lesson is simple: governments make better decisions when they listen. Whether it is the controversy surrounding bus seat belt rules or the debate over the regulation of ride-hailing services, policy measures are more likely to succeed when informed by feedback from the people directly affected.


Third, the government should strengthen cross-departmental coordination and implementation discipline. Many policies fail not because they lack vision but because they become trapped within administrative silos.
A credible five-year framework should establish clear priorities, assign responsibilities, define milestones and create regular review mechanisms. Without such discipline in implementation, even the best intentions can dissipate over time.
Hong Kong’s first five-year plan is an opportunity to strengthen the city’s capacity to govern effectively as challenges become more complex than ever. It demands we learn from useful governance practices wherever they can be found, and adapt them to Hong Kong’s circumstances. A most relevant source of learning is mainland China.
In the end, people care less about political theories than practical results. The true test of any governing system is whether people can see, touch and feel the improvements it delivers in their daily lives.


Hong Kong’s political, business elite pay final respects to Tung Chee-hwa

Top Hong Kong officials, business leaders mourn Tung Chee-hwa – as it happened

Hong Kong leader says firms must strive to survive despite government support

Patriot dedicated to Hong Kong: business heavyweights remember Tung Chee-hwa

Hong Kong politics

Hong Kong’s five-year plan must boost governance to ensure results

Chief Executive John Lee Ka-chiu arrives to meet the press at the government headquarters in Admiralty on February 10. Photo: Elson Li

Hong Kong to begin consultation on ‘historic’ first 5-year plan on June 15

A two-month consultation to shape Hong Kong’s first five-year roadmap will begin on June 15, city leader John Lee has confirmed. Photo: May Tse

The first five-year plan is expected to steer Hong Kong’s economy, industry, infrastructure, healthcare and education. Photo: Eugene Lee

The blueprint is designed to align Hong Kong’s economy, land and welfare policies with Beijing’s national strategy. Photo: Edmond So

‘My way or the highway’ is no way to make informed policy for Hong Kong

Chief Executive John Lee listens to views during a 2025 policy address district forum on July 27, 2025. Photo: ISD

Financial Secretary Paul Chan Mo-po delivers the budget at the Legislative Council on February 25. Photo: Eugene Lee

Tam Yiu-chung, then vice-president of the Chinese Association of Hong Kong and Macau Studies, speaks at the “one country, two systems” and Basic Law seminar at the Harbour Grand Hong Kong hotel in North Point on November 23, 2023. Photo: Jelly Tse

Hong Kong’s old buildings: 5 lessons for urban renewal

People walk past “Blue House”, a four-storey tenement block on Stone Nullah Lane, Wan Chai, on August 29, 2024. Photo: May Tse

The Lui Seng Chun tong lau in Sham Shui Po, seen on August 29, 2024. Photo: May Tse

The real story of 11 Skies is not about a failed shopping centre

11 Skies is a 3.8 million sq ft mixed‑use retail and entertainment complex at Skycity near Hong Kong International Airport in Chek Lap Kok, seen here on May 27. Photo: Sam Tsang

Opinion

Hong Kong Opinion

News

Hong Kong

Politics

Society

Hong Kong Economy

The challenge is not simply identifying problems. It is mustering the political will and building the capacity to overcome them


The challenge is not simply identifying problems. It is mustering the political will and building the capacity to overcome them.


Hong Kong society

John Lee

Chief Executive (Hong Kong)

Legislative Council of Hong Kong (Legco)

China

Hong Kong economy

Hong Kong housing

Urban planning

Poverty

Hong Kong population

Ageing society

Hong Kong’s Tai Po fire tragedy

Uber

Hong Kong taxis

Expresses the views, ideas and conclusions of the author. (Eg. Enough of Crazy Rich Asians, think of crazy poor Hongkongers.)


Hong Kong’s five-year plan must boost governance to ensure results

.css-1c6uqr6{color:inherit;font-weight:inherit;font-size:inherit;font-family:inherit;line-height:inherit;overflow-wrap:break-word;}The challenge is not simply identifying problems. It is mustering the political will and building the capacity to overcome them

The challenge is not simply identifying problems. It is mustering the political will and building the capacity to overcome them