appConfigEntityId

bodyType

customContents

entityId

entityUuid

isVideo

articlePageQuery

article

articleSchemaContent

content

hooksArticlePageAdvertisementConfigArticle

hooksArticlePageFloatingButtonConfigArticle

appConfig

filter

json

liveArticle

Rob York

America’s reputation has been bruised in many parts of the world due to its actions, from destabilising uncooperative governments, overruling the mandate of newly elected foreign leaders and, in extreme cases, invading other countries.
In recent years, its position has improved somewhat, not so much by its own doing but by those of its competitors and adversaries, which have shown they are not above pressuring foreign leaders, threatening outright hostilities or, as with Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, making good on those threats.
The actions of Russia and China, for instance, help to show that while America’s reach and means may be unique among so-called global powers, its inability to mind its own business is sadly typical.
This streak of default good publicity had to end at some point, and recent allegations that the US ran a covert campaign to encourage scepticism in the Philippines towards Covid-19 vaccines during the pandemic constitutes a clear embarrassment.
According to the June 14 Reuters report, the secretive initiative, launched in the waning days of the Trump administration, intended to erode confidence among the Philippine public towards vaccines – not just Chinese-made Sinovac jabs but vaccines in general. “COVID came from China and the VACCINE also came from China, don’t trust China!” one such tweet read in Tagalog.


First, it must be reiterated that this was a Trump administration initiative that the Biden administration discontinued in early 2021. Second, there will certainly be attempts by Donald Trump’s supporters and other foreign policy “realists” to dismiss the ethical concerns related to such measures, arguing that Chinese influence in the Philippines was harmful under the dovish administration of Rodrigo Duterte.
They may also argue that the efficacy of Chinese-made vaccines was less than worthy of confidence, and that China is in no position to decry others’ use of disinformation campaigns.
A mountain of evidence suggests Beijing has used its extensive “50-cent gang”, for example, to spread false and misleading messages at both ends of the Pacific, as well as to allegedly influence elections and undermine confidence. The Philippines has reportedly been a target of such influence operations.
Furthermore, there are real concerns about how useful the Sinovac jab was, with Singapore’s National Centre for Infectious Diseases, for instance, saying its efficacy trailed far behind that of the Pfizer or Moderna vaccine.
But the issues related to Chinese-made vaccines and efforts to misinform the public in the Philippines are among the reasons the alleged US covert campaign was a mistake.
At the time, late in the Duterte administration, frustration among the Philippine public was already boiling over towards Chinese activity in the South China Sea and Duterte’s appeasement. Unhappiness with his China policy ultimately led to the election of Ferdinand Marcos Jnr, another right-of-centre candidate less willing to accommodate Beijing.


Also, the US could have placed its trust in the ingenuity of its scientists to produce a better vaccine than China’s – the Singaporean centre’s report evaluated the Sinovac vaccine’s efficacy against severe disease at just 60 per cent, compared to Moderna’s 97 per cent and Pfizer’s 90 per cent.
A realist argument for efforts to undermine China and its vaccines in the Philippines therefore fails due to a lack of, well, realism, as Beijing’s actions and methods would have accomplished that on its own.
But arguments against covert programmes to mislead the public in other countries cannot merely be pragmatic. We live in a time of democratic backsliding in much of the world, a process aided by widespread efforts in democratic countries to undermine public confidence and social cohesion through rumours, half-truths and outright deceit.
The US has established new government agencies, including the Global Engagement Centre in the State Department, to fight such trends and promote fact-based narratives. Such efforts may ring hollow now – though it is somewhat fortunate for the US that this took place in the Philippines, and that Beijing’s conduct near Second Thomas Shoal continues to provide a distraction.


Furthermore, whatever one thinks of the Sinovac jab, it is simply unconscionable for a US administration to undermine public confidence in a partner country towards vaccination. Even a 60-per-cent-effective vaccine would have constituted an improvement in 2020 and 2021, when Covid-19 infections were claiming thousands of lives daily. In the Philippines alone, more than 60,000 would die of the disease before the worst had passed.
At the height of the pandemic, the argument from health professionals was that a vaccine was our quickest way out of the international public-health crisis. The Trump administration did the important work of promoting rapid vaccine deployment through “Operation Warp Speed”, making safe and effective treatment for Covid-19 available in a relatively short span of time.
Unfortunately, its alleged covert campaign might also have contributed to a vaccine hesitancy in Philippines that is higher than its neighbours’. The bad press will probably outlive Trump, while attempts to paint it as a Trump-era policy will probably count for little, given the overarching continuity in US policy towards China, with tariffs, prohibitions on tech cooperation and expansions of security partnerships designed to rein in China’s ambitions.
Those of us who still support a US-led world order should encourage better from our leaders, including a possible second Trump administration. US-led efforts to preserve a free and open Indo-Pacific depend on Washington’s ability to build partnerships in the region – a willingness to put lives in other countries at risk is poison for such partnerships.
Rob York is programme director for regional affairs at the Pacific Forum


Xi-Trump summit, China AI at Brics, Asian Games

US families ramp up efforts for loved ones’ release from China ahead of Xi’s visit

US trade chief pressed Brazil to review Anglo American nickel sale to China

US approves sale of 48 F-35 jets to Saudi Arabia despite Israeli concerns

US-China relations

No good reason for US to spread anti-vax rumours in the Philippines

Rodrigo Duterte, then president of the Philippines, receives a Chinese Covid-19 vaccine at the presidential palace in Manila on May 3, 2021, to encourage more Filippinos to get vaccinated amid the pandemic. Photo: Malacanang Presidential Photographers Division via AP

Amid Philippine anger over US anti-vax report, possible fallout could benefit China: analysts

A staff member transports cargos containing Sinovac vaccines donated by the Chinese government in Pasay City, the Philippines, in December 2021. Photo: Xinhua

A man is inoculated with China’s Sinovac Covid-19 vaccine in Quezon City, the Philippines, in September 2021. Photo: AP

Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte (left) is inoculated with China’s Sinopharm Covid-19 vaccine by Health Secretary Fracisco Duque III at the Malacanang presidential palace in Manila on May 3, 2021. Photo: Malacanang Presidential Photographers Division via AP

People use mobile phones in Taguig City in May. Analyst Don McLain Gill says the Philippines “is a known victim of various disinformation campaigns”. Photo: Bloomberg

Asean all adrift over South China Sea consensus

Illustration: Craig Stephens

Malaysian Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim and Philippine President Ferdinand Marcos Jnr (right), are separated by Myanmar’s empty seat, at the 26th Asean-Japan Summit in Jakarta, Indonesia, on September 6. Photo: Reuters

South China Sea: why the Philippines needs a Chinese energy deal

Opinion

China Opinion

Asia Opinion

World Opinion

Knowledge

Topics

Coronavirus Vaccine

News

Asia

Southeast Asia

Whatever one thinks of the Sinovac jab, it is unconscionable to undermine public confidence towards vaccines in a partner country during a pandemic


Whatever one thinks of the Sinovac jab, it is unconscionable to undermine public confidence towards vaccines in a partner country during a pandemic.


Chinese coronavirus vaccines

Coronavirus Philippines

Coronavirus pandemic: All stories

Coronavirus pandemic

The Philippines

Coronavirus vaccine

Donald Trump

Diplomacy

Disease

Rodrigo Duterte

Expresses the views, ideas and conclusions of the author. (Eg. Enough of Crazy Rich Asians, think of crazy poor Hongkongers.)


No good reason for US to spread anti-vax rumours in the Philippines

.css-1mniedq{color:inherit;font-weight:inherit;font-size:inherit;font-family:inherit;line-height:inherit;}Whatever one thinks of the Sinovac jab, it is unconscionable to undermine public confidence towards vaccines in a partner country during a pandemic

Whatever one thinks of the Sinovac jab, it is unconscionable to undermine public confidence towards vaccines in a partner country during a pandemic