Advertisement
United States
OpinionAsia Opinion
Anthony Rowley

Macroscope | Trump’s tariffs are waking Asia up from the dream of export-led growth

Asian economies responded to Western exhortations to pursue export-led growth. The resulting ‘economic miracle’ now looks like a mistake

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
3
A protester wearing a Trump mask at a demonstration against the US tariffs policy and to demand South Korea’s Acting President Han Duck-soo and Finance Minister Choi Sang-mok resign, in Seoul, South Korea, on April 22. Photo: AP

Imagine driving slowly but steadily along the road towards an economic development led by domestic demand, when your navigator advises you to take a faster route via export-led growth. You duly comply – only to find the road blocked by huge tariff barriers.

Your navigator then advises reversing out of the cul de sac and choosing yet another way to proceed – which will be a difficult, time-consuming and potentially expensive process, he warns. What do you do? Tear your hair out or jettison the navigator and find your own way forward?

This is a rough analogy of the situation in which many Asian economies find themselves as the brave (but broken) new world of Trump’s tariffs lays bare the obstacle-littered way ahead.

Advertisement
In the decades just after World War II, East Asian nations led by Japan and the four Asian “tiger economies” of South Korea, Taiwan, Hong Kong and Singapore responded to urgings of Western economists to adopt open economies and export-led growth models. In contrast, India, for instance, chose an import substitution policy – taxing foreign goods to encourage local manufacturing – covering everything from motorbikes to machine tools.

The dependence on exports has, however, led many economies into a blind alley as the US market retreats behind tariff walls and the Chinese market becomes increasingly self-sufficient, alongside probably a growing number in Europe. The supply chain route to export-led growth is likely to be at least partially closed too.

Advertisement

All this cannot be blamed entirely upon the Trump tariffs. Pernicious trends have been apparent for some time with the overdependence on consumption and imports in the US and other Western markets (with accompanying trade imbalances) becoming increasingly unsustainable, politically and economically. But US President Donald Trump’s “no entry” sign has brought things to a screeching halt.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x