Advertisement
Hong Kong

A societal calling to check Hong Kong youth in all its daring and righteous indignation

Biology dictates students thrive on thrills, so it is up to grown-ups to point them in right way

2-MIN READ2-MIN
(From left) Joshua Wong Chi-fung, Nathan Law Kwun-chung and Alex Chow Yong-kang arrive Eastern Court for the pre-trial review in October, 2015. It takes courage and commitment for students to throw themselves into the dark and dirty valley of politics. Photo: Edward Wong
Perry Lam

These days, students - full of righteous indignation, swearing and pointing accusing fingers at people they regard as moral inferiors - have become a fixture on television. What I find both perplexing and disturbing is how utterly convinced they seem to be of their infallibility. They would not back down or apologise, insisting they are in the right. They have absolutely no use for self-doubt.

It takes courage and commitment for students to throw themselves into the dark and dirty valley of politics. What they need is a more nuanced moral sense and a capacity for self-reflection. So often, they convey the impression that making tough moral choices, between integrity and justice, for example, is effortless. By their calculation, the potential political benefits always outweigh the moral costs of paying for their decisions.

Such decisiveness is worrying. What is wrong with student leaders flip-flopping?

Let politicians pretend they have it all figured out. Students are not running for office. They are not slaves to the interests of their constituencies because they don't have one. By changing their minds and admitting they are sometimes wrong or even clueless, they would be doing our society a great service. We need to keep an open mind because there are things we simply do not know. What is best for society cannot be decided by any single shade of political persuasion.

Select Voice
Select Speed
1x
AI-generated voice