Shift to ‘strategic clarity’ on Taiwan a further risk to US-China relations

There are growing calls in Washington for an explicit commitment to defend the island from attack

But some voices argue policy of ambiguity has prevented war for 40 years despite provocations from both sides

Reading Time:7 minutes

Published: 12:00am, 11 Sep 2020Updated: 1:23am, 12 Sep 2020

As voters in the United States prepare for the presidential election in November, the South China Morning Post is exploring the potential ramifications for China. The sixth part of the series looks at the debate in Washington over its long-standing policy on Taiwan.

Growing calls for a potentially explosive shift in US policy on Taiwan to an explicit commitment to defend the self-ruled island from Chinese attack are threatening to further undermine the already dismal ties between Washington and Beijing.

For decades, Washington has remained studiously vague on exactly what it would do if cross-strait tensions “went kinetic”, given long-standing threats by Beijing to reassert control over the island, by force if necessary.

But shifting power politics are leading some to conclude that a reboot in the US policy known as “strategic ambiguity” is needed. The renewed debate has surfaced before, only to disappear – most notably during the 1995-96 Taiwan Strait Crisis when Beijing landed missiles near the island – and comes amid a hotly contested presidential campaign that could affect any decision.

US aircraft carrier Nimitz on its way to the Taiwan Strait during the 1996 crisis. Photo: Reuters

Among those believed to support a more explicit US stance are White House deputy national security adviser Matthew Pottinger, Secretary of State Mike Pompeo, parts of the Pentagon and many in Congress.

Those viewed as supporting the status quo include officials focused on the US-China economic relationship, namely US Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer and Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin. President Donald Trump has not weighed in with his views.

SCMP Series

China, America and the US elections

[ 6 of 24 ]

Shift to ‘strategic clarity’ on Taiwan a further risk to US-China relations

There are growing calls in Washington for an explicit commitment to defend the island from attack But some voices argue policy of ambiguity has prevented war for 40 years despite provocations from both sides

There are growing calls in Washington for an explicit commitment to defend the island from attack

But some voices argue policy of ambiguity has prevented war for 40 years despite provocations from both sides