bodyType

customContents

entityId

entityUuid

articlePageQuery

filter

article

articleBaseAdvertisingInfoArticle

articleListArticle

articleSeoArticle

helpersCheckIsPostiesArticle

hooksArticleAcknowledgementGateOverlayArticle

hooksTrackPageViewArticle

hooksContentInterestArticle

articleLinkingDataContent

articleSchemaContent

liveArticle

advertZone

sentiment

contentLock

topics

types

sections

moreOnThisArticles

urlAlias

commentCount

sponsorType

authorLocations

authors

paywallTypes

corrections

displaySlideShow

multimediaEmbed

printHeadline

seriesContainer

socialHeadline

headline

flag

firstTopic

glossary

flattenTypeIds

publishedDate

additionalInfoBoxes

images

image

relatedLinks

relatedNewsletters

__typename

createdDate

sponsor

factSheets

series

disableOffPlatformContent

published

updatedDate

summary

subHeadline

body

keywords

copyrighted

customTimezone

liveContents

Graeme Green

In April 2023, British photographer Jack Latham waited on a Hong Kong street for a person he knew only as M.
The two men had exchanged messages on WhatsApp and Telegram for nearly a year and Latham had flown out from London hoping M would lead him into the shadowy world of click farms in the city.
Despite being unaware of their existence, we feel the effects of click farms every day, from the products we buy to the political ideas we support, says Latham.
“A click farm is an organisation whose sole purpose is to manipulate the analytics of social media or online content,” he says.
“They do this through liking people’s accounts or posts, increasing views on YouTube videos, leaving positive comments or reviews […] All to make something look artificially more popular than it is, in the hopes of changing the public’s opinion about something.
“They are popularity machines.”

While click farms are not new, they are getting more efficient.
At a “traditional” operation, a click farmer who owns hundreds of mobile phones or computers, each with a unique IP address, would have to physically interact with each device to like posts and follow accounts.
At modern operations – so-called box farms – everything can be hooked up to a single computer, on which farmers can control any device at the click of a mouse.
This is also more space-efficient, as devices can be arranged into tightfitting racks with no need to interact with them physically.
“One of the bigger click farms we visited had different floors filled with thousands of phones,” says Latham. “They can do hundreds of thousands of accounts and likes per day.
“If your perception and understanding of the world comes from the information that you’re digesting,” he adds, “if someone is able to manipulate what your diet of information is, all of a sudden you can become, to use the food analogy, ‘diabetic’.
“The way social media is being used now as a proxy for soft politics is remarkable.”

Latham, a 34-year-old senior lecturer in photography at the University of the West of England, in Bristol, particularly worries about the effect such manipulation could have on younger generations.
“All the students that I teach experience the world and the news through their phones. There’s so much content thrown at you, at such a rapid pace, that people end up trusting the analytics a lot more than they realise.
“They think, ‘This is something a lot of people seem to be interacting with, therefore it must be true.’ Or, ‘This video has 30,000 views, so I’ll watch it, because other people have watched it.’
“You don’t have time to think about what you’re digesting.”
Latham has spent the past decade exploring conspiracies and the swirling mess of misinformation online – and in people’s minds.
He started working on his Beggar’s Honey book project, which addresses false narratives online, in 2019, conducting research and establishing contacts, including via hacker forums.

He was set to travel to Asia in April 2020, but the pandemic halted his plans, which caused further problems.
“It’s an ever-changing industry,” he says. “You might have several contacts one month, then they’ve all moved to different countries the next or are running away from legislation.”
The legality of click farms is a grey area and changes from country to country, he says, although their activity violates the terms and conditions of social media companies such as Meta.
“Within Vietnam, it’s sort of an open secret,” he says, “[whereas] someone I spoke to in Germany, who was building his own click farm, was utterly terrified of being found out.”
Mainland China has had an Anti-Unfair Competition Law since 1993. A 2017 amendment introduced prohibitions on false user ratings, “honours” or sales amounts to mislead customers, seemingly targeting click farms.
The same year, Chinese e-commerce company Alibaba (owner of the South China Morning Post) won a legal case against Hangzhou Jianshi Technology, the company behind click-farm site Shatui, for what was judged as fraudulent practices, including inflating sales numbers and creating bogus reviews.

Click farmers have also been arrested in countries including Thailand and India over the past decade.
“[In mainland China] click farms can now be charged under new legislation and from 2018 onwards, more farms are finding themselves facing court cases,” says Latham.
He explains that when his contacts in mainland China went to ground, he started looking for other click farmers and found three in Hong Kong.
The scheduled meeting with M in 2023 never happened. “He got cold feet,” says Latham. “I think he got anxious. It was all planned: we would visit his set-up and take photographs – not of him, just his set-up.
“He decided not to show up [and blocked our phone numbers], which was frustrating.”
Instead, Latham visited the registered Hong Kong addresses of the businesses he suspected to be click farms and photographed their exteriors. For an inside look, however, he had to turn his attention to Vietnam.

“Vietnam has very quickly become the place for click farms. Electricity is also very cheap, which is a key advantage.
“You go into a space and you’re blown away by the technology. They thought it was quite funny that I wanted to take photos of what, in their eyes, is just machinery.
“We visited one click farm that’s on the top floor of a hotel and seemed like a tech start-up. Everyone there was under the age of 24, and they had seven or eight employees.
“We went to another on the outskirts of Hanoi, which was multistorey but a family-run business. Others had just a single person.”





By helping expose click farms, Latham hopes to make people more aware of how misleading user ratings, views and like counts can be, so that they will start to question the authenticity of the content they encounter online.
“It’s easier to fight the monster with the lights turned on and knowing what it looks like,” he says. “I’d love for people to be more cautious of how they interact or give credence to something on social media.
“I’m concerned about the amount of information each person learns about the world from their phones these days. It’s terrifying.”


Actor Chow Yun-fat, showing his photographs of Hong Kong, says ‘It works when it’s right’

5 of the best things to do in Hong Kong this weekend, December 13-15

Inside the evolution of travel photography in Hong Kong

Photographer’s images of post-war Hong Kong get overdue exposure in exhibition

Photography

Inside a click farm – exposé on how they work in plain sight, in Hong Kong and Vietnam

A click farmer at work in Vietnam. Photo: Jack Latham

A click farmer at work in Vietnam. Click farms can employ thousands of devices to manipulate how popular online content or products appear. They operate in several places, including Hong Kong. Photo: Jack Latham

A single phone, part of a bank of devices, in a “traditional” click farm. Photo: Jack Latham

After the Samsung S7 was recalled because of batteries exploding, they flooded the market. As a result, click farmers often purchase them and remove the batteries themselves. Photo: Jack Latham

A collection of box farms in Vietnam. Photo: Jack Latham

 The alleged location of a click farm in Hong Kong. Photo: Jack Latham

The online registered address of a click farm in Hong Kong. Photo: Jack Latham

Phones at a click farm that specialises in Facebook metrics. Photo: Jack Latham

Because of the heat created by box farms, some farms install “butcher curtains” to keep all of the cool air contained within the room. Photo: Jack Latham

A click farmer, who wishes to remain anonymous, in his office in Vietnam. Photo: Jack Latham

An evolution of the traditional “click farm” – these box farms contain 20 phones within a casing, all with the screens and batteries removed. Photo: Jack Latham

An assembly area for box farms in Vietnam. Photo: Jack Latham

Work of ‘Uncle Kiu’, former Post chief photographer, goes on show at special exhibition in Hong Kong News-Expo

An exhibition of work by veteran Post photographer Chan Kiu is on show at the Hong Kong News-Expo in Central. Photo: Xiaomei Chen

South China Morning Post star photographer Chan Kiu in the 1980s. An exhibition of striking images captured by his camera is on at the Hong Kong News-Expo. Photo: SCMP

Garmen Chan says he never heard a bad word said about Uncle Kiu. Photo: Xiaomei Chen

Journalist and true-crime podcaster pursues justice for Australian women murder victims

Journalist, author and podcaster Hedley Thomas talks about his life and career. Photo: Justine Walpole

Journalist and author Hedley Thomas, whose investigations of cold-case murders of Australian women have delivered belated justice, tells Post Magazine about the power of podcasts for journalism. Photo: Justine Walpole

Hedley Thomas pins a medal onto his father, circa 1977. Photo: Hedley Robert Thomas

Thomas in 1987 at a murder scene when he was a reporter at the Gold Coast Bulletin. Photo: Hedley Thomas

Thomas and his wife-to-be Ruth Mathewson at the Hong Kong Press Club Ball in 1993. Photo: Hedley Thomas

Thomas and Mathewson getting married in 1995. Photo: Hedley Thomas

Thomas and his wife in Hong Kong in early 1999. Photo: Hedley Thomas

Thomas with his wife in 2007 in Queensland, Australia. Photo: Hedley Thomas

Thomas speaks to the media in Sydney, Australia on August 30, 2022, after Chris Dawson was found guilty of murdering his first wife in 1982. Photo: Getty Images

Thomas in Australia in 2023. He is working on a new podcast series called Bronwyn. Photo: Hedley Thomas

Dying to be famous: the Chinese live-streamers killing themselves for clicks, and the lure of online careers

Chinese influencer Cuihua, who died while attempting to lose weight. Photo: Getty ImagesPhoto: Douyin / Cuihua

Mega influencer Li Jiaqi, known as the “Lipstick King”, applies lipstick while livestreaming. Celebrity live-streamers like him, with their large fan bases and selling power, are becoming an increasingly significant part of the Chinese economy. But as some literally die for views, questions must be asked. Photo: Getty Images

Mega influencer Li Jiaqi, known as the “Lipstick King”, applies lipstick while livestreaming. Celebrity live-streamers like him, with their large fan bases and selling power, are becoming an increasingly significant part of the Chinese economy. Photo: Getty Images

The Douyin account of Chinese live-streamer Li Jiaqi. Influencers with large followings can make considerable amounts of money on Chinese social media. Photo: Douyin / Li Jiaqi

Li Jiaqi, who rose to fame on Chinese social media as the “Lipstick King”, has nearly 45 million fans on Douyin. Photo: Getty Images

Li Jiaqi’s Douyin account. The live-streamer once sold 15,000 lipsticks in five minutes. Photo: Douyin / Li Jiaqi

Chinese live-streamer Papi Jiang amassed 44 million followers in one year. Photo: Douyin/Papi Jiang

Papi Jiang’s Douyin account. Photo: Papi Jiang

Chinese influencer Cuihua, who died while attempting to lose weight. Photo: Douyin / Cuihua

Sanqiange died after live-streaming a drinking challenge on TikTok. Photo Douyin / Sanqiange

Stop taking ‘selfish selfies’ with captive wildlife, charity says, urging tourists to boycott photo trade driven by social media that fuels animal cruelty

Russian tennis player Anastasia Pavlyuchenkova takes selfies with a Koala  during the Australian Open Tennis Tournament in Melbourne in January. Photo: AFP

In its report “Selfish Selfies: The Exploitation of Captive Wild Animals for Souvenir Photos”, wildlife charity Born Free highlights the dark side of the animal souvenir photo trade. Photo: Born Free

Rory Eliza has a souvenir photo taken with a captive monkey. Photo: TikTok / @roryeliza

Australian influencer Rory Eliza has gone viral denouncing the taking of photos with captive animals, but Tennis Australia has promoted the practice by publishing an image of Russia’s Anastasia Pavlyuchenkova taking a selfie with a koala. Photo: AFP

A tourist poses with a tiger at Wat Pha Luang Ta Bua Yanasampanno Forest Monastery in Kanchanaburi, Thailand. Photo: Getty Images

Saengduean Chailert, also known as Lek, is the founder of Chiang Mai, Thailand-based Save Elephant Foundation. Photo: Save Elephant Foundation.

Lek says that, as well as riding elephants, feeding milk to baby elephants is a tourist trend that must stop. Photo: Save Elephant Foundation

‘You cannot win’: deepfake porn could be a growing problem for women amid AI race

Deepfake creators have disseminated similar videos and images targeting online influencers, journalists and others with a public profile. Photo: Shutterstock

Experts fear the darker side of the easily accessible tools could worsen something that primarily harms women: nonconsensual deepfake pornography. Photo: Shutterstock

Gaming platform Twitch also recently updated its policies around explicit deepfake images after a popular streamer named Atrioc was discovered to have a deepfake porn website open on his browser during a livestream in late January. Photo: Reuters

Magazines

PostMag

Lifestyle

Gadgets

Photographer sees inside a click farm, where computers control banks of phones that manipulate how popular online content appears


Photographer sees inside a click farm in Vietnam, where computers control thousands of devices to manipulate online content. Similar operations are present in Hong Kong.


Internet

Social media

Hanoi

Photo essay