‘Music everyone can relate to,’ Mahler’s symphonies celebrated in Amsterdam festival

When Klaus Mäkelä climbed the Concertgebouw podium in Amsterdam and turned to the audience at the orchestra’s third Gustav Mahler Festival in 105 years, the conductor could see the writing on the wall. Facing him was “MAHLER” etched in gold on a cartouche and shining in a spotlight, centred in a permanent position of honour among the 17 composers enshrined across the balcony front. And sitting in the first row directly behind the sign was Marina Mahler, the composer’s 81-year-old granddaughter. “It was just as it should be. I was terribly moved and excited at the same time,” she said after the final note of Mahler’s Symphony No 1. “It affected me in the deepest possible way.” All 10 of Mahler’s numbered symphonies are being presented in order along with his other major works from May 8-18, ending on the 114th anniversary of his death at age 50. “This is in a way the first orchestra that really trusted in Mahler,” Mäkela said. Joining the Royal Concertgebouw Orchestra were the Budapest Festival Orchestra, NHK Symphony Orchestra, Chicago Symphony Orchestra and Berlin Philharmonic, with conducting split among Mäkelä (Symphonies 1 and 8), Iván Fischer (2 and 5), Fabio Luisi (3 and 4), Jaap van Zweden (6 and 7), Kirill Petrenko (9) and Sakari Oramo (10). Programmes are simulcast to a 1,500-seat amphitheatre in Amsterdam’s Vondelpark. “We have a US orchestra for the first time in this festival,” said Simon Reinink, who headed the planning as general director of The Concertgebouw (the building, as opposed to the orchestra). “We also thought why shouldn’t we invite an Asian orchestra?” Mahler’s first champion was Willem Mengelberg, who conducted the entirety of the first Mahler Festival in 1920 to celebrate his 25th anniversary as the Concertgebouw’s chief conductor. A second festival was held in 1995 to mark the 75th anniversary of the first festival and a 100th anniversary celebration was planned for 2020 and cancelled because of the coronavirus pandemic. “Mahler is really in the DNA of the orchestra,” said Dominik Winterling, managing director of the Royal Concertgebouw Orchestra. “You feel it because we have a certain tradition, which is also passed on from generation to generation.” Bruno Walter and Leonard Bernstein were Mahler’s other primary proponents in the 20th century. “My father, who was a musician, always told me: ‘Mahler was a great conductor and a good composer with some problems. Usually the form is not perfect and it’s formless’,” Iván Fischer said of Sándor Fischer, also a conductor. When Bernstein led the Vienna Philharmonic in all of Mahler’s symphonies over a decade starting in the mid-1960s, there was resistance. “In intervals, in corridors, everywhere musicians talk to each other, there was this: ‘Yes, it’s good music but a little kitsch. Well, why does he need these bombastic effects?’” Iván Fischer recalled. “Really the cult of Mahler, where everybody started to love it, came after this cycle of Bernstein in Vienna but it was a spirit of the time. I think what created the breakthrough was that you didn’t feel that music had to comport to certain norms and so it was a little liberation of the ’60s, the time of free love, Beatles.” He is such a human and we are such a witness of all the emotional roller coasters and beauty and sadness and everything in his life Conductor Jaap van Zweden on the nature of Mahler’s music Mahler has gained acceptance. The fifth symphony’s “Adagietto” was conducted by Bernstein at US Senator Robert F. Kennedy’s funeral and is featured in Luchino Visconti’s 1971 film Death in Venice and 2022’s Tár. His Symphony No 2 sets a mood in a current Tony Award nominee, The Picture of Dorian Gray. Though just 29, Mäkelä was a natural fit to lead off with the first symphony because he becomes both Concertgebouw chief conductor and Chicago Symphony Orchestra music director for the 2027-28 season. He stepped exuberantly down two dozen steps towards the podium to open his programme with Anders Hillborg’s Hell Mountain, a world premiere commissioned for the festival that quotes two of Mahler’s works. Former Hong Kong Philharmonic music director Van Zweden, who has a home a short walk from the Concertgebouw, was to open the cancelled 2020 festival with the New York Philharmonic, when he was its music director. Van Zweden first heard Mahler when he was six or seven, a Symphony No 4 led by Bernard Haitink, the Concertgebouw’s chief conductor from 1961 to 1988. A violinist in his youth, van Zweden became the orchestra’s youngest concertmaster at age 19. “The scores of Mahler, what he gave us is a GPS system about the road of his life,” he said. “He is such a human and we are such a witness of all the emotional roller coasters and beauty and sadness and everything in his life during that performance. That is a different experience than a Tchaikovsky symphony.” Luisi first heard Mahler when he attended a performance of the composer’s Symphony No 5 as a 15-year-old in Genoa, Italy. “It was overwhelming. I didn’t know that this music could be so passionate and intense all the time – such a long symphony with a lot of different characters, different feelings, different moods,” he recalled. “I remember getting out of that concert shaking in pleasure and surprise.” Mäkelä used a new edition of the score for No 1 compiled by Michael Waterman, the fifth member of his family to play in the Concertgebouw in a lineage dating to 1950. With the help of his mother, Cleora, and friend Silvio Scambone, Waterman compiled markings going back to 1967. He now is working on editions of the fifth and ninth symphonies based on notations dating to Mengelberg, who headed the orchestra from 1895 to 1945 before he was banned for his collaboration with Nazis. On May 10, Fischer took a five-minute break between the first and second movements of Symphony No 2, specified by Mahler but not often followed. In a hall famous for its precise acoustics, he drew breathtaking playing from horns that scampered on and off stage like NFL special teams. “So you hear these trumpets from heaven, everywhere, different directions,” he said. Mäkelä is convinced Mahler has become more accessible in current times. “It speaks to the audience now because it’s music that everyone can relate to,” he said. “Because it’s so personal, it somehow gives you a possibility to self-reflect.”

‘Music everyone can relate to,’ Mahler’s symphonies celebrated in Amsterdam festival

.css-1c6uqr6{color:inherit;font-weight:inherit;font-size:inherit;font-family:inherit;line-height:inherit;overflow-wrap:break-word;}Amsterdam’s Concertgebouw, the first orchestra to champion Mahler’s music, among the ensembles performing at festival devoted to composer

Amsterdam’s Concertgebouw, the first orchestra to champion Mahler’s music, among the ensembles performing at festival devoted to composer