appConfigEntityId

bodyType

customContents

entityId

entityUuid

isVideo

articlePageQuery

article

articleSchemaContent

content

hooksArticlePageAdvertisementConfigArticle

hooksArticlePageFloatingButtonConfigArticle

appConfig

filter

json

liveArticle

Harry Pearl

China risks being left behind as South Korea and Japan signal a shift away from financing overseas coal power in response to growing criticism over their support for the dirty fossil fuel.
The three countries are the top global lenders for coal energy infrastructure, bankrolling projects beyond their borders through export credit agencies and developing new markets to export coal plant technology.
But there are signs that Japan and South Korea may be preparing to scale back official support amid mounting pressure from the public and investors on environmental grounds.
Japan announced last month that it would tighten funding criteria for foreign coal-fired power plants, and next month South Korean lawmakers will debate several bills aimed at banning overseas coal investment as part of a post-coronavirus “Green New Deal”.
Chinese renewable energy investment abroad soars – but coal still dominant
“This is profoundly serious, because it is an acceleration of a trend that is already established in global financial markets,” said Melissa Brown, the director of energy finance studies, Asia, at the Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis.
“It has a very strong economic foundation, which is that – based on virtually all of the coherent and credible evidence we have today – coal-fired power facilities that are brought into service in the next five years are extremely unlikely to have a productive, profitable economic life.”
Banks, multilateral lenders and governments across the world are ditching coal as renewable technology gets cheaper and the climate crisis becomes more pressing.
Two of Japan’s largest commercial banks, Mizuho Financial Group and Sumitomo Mitsui Financial Group, said earlier this year that they would cease funding for new coal power projects in the face of pressure from climate activists.
Global financial institutions such as BlackRock, France’s AXA and the Royal Bank of Scotland have also announced coal-divestment policies in the past eight months.
Though Japan’s updated investment policy has been criticised by environmentalists for leaving loopholes, the South Korean legislation on foreign financing, if passed, could be a landmark change from one of the world’s biggest backers of the carbon-intensive fuel.
Coal is no longer the least-cost power option, even without accounting for its external costs like pollution and climate impacts
Christine Shearer, Global Energy Monitor
Christine Shearer, from Global Energy Monitor, an NGO that supports the phasing out of fossil fuels, said the Japanese and South Korean governments were starting to “accept the new reality”.
“The economics have changed, and coal is no longer the least-cost power option, even without accounting for its external costs like pollution and climate impacts,” she said.
Environmental campaigners hope the moves by Japan and South Korea will put pressure on China, but whether the world’s largest financier of coal energy will take similar steps remains to be seen.
Explainer: How climate change will affect Asia
China has an outsize impact on development financing for coal. From 2000-2019, its two global policy banks – the China Development Bank and the Export-Import Bank of China – issued loans totalling US$51.8 billion for coal energy projects around the world, according to the Global Development Policy Centre at Boston University.
In comparison, Japan spent US$26 billion financing 36 overseas coal-fired power plants between January 2003 and April 2019, the Japan Centre for a Sustainable Environment and Society estimated.
South Korean public financial institutions, meanwhile, supported 24 overseas coal projects with US$10 billion from 2008 to 2018, according to Solutions For Our Climate (SFOC), a Seoul-based non-profit organisation.
Analysts say China will continue to be the primary global backer of coal power for the foreseeable future.
Its blend of technical know-how on coal combustion; a state-backed system that provides cheap financing and favours large-scale projects, thereby disadvantaging renewables; and the welcoming attitude of recipient countries will continue to favour financing abroad, said Li Shuo, senior climate and energy policy officer for Greenpeace East Asia.
If they want coal, who are we to tell them not to fund coal? That is the current host country principle that China applies in overseas financing
Christoph Nedopil Wang
But calls are growing for China to make green investing a keystone of Xi Jinping’s signature Belt and Road Initiative.
If emissions standards are not improved in the 126 countries involved in the belt and road plan, global temperatures could be pushed up by nearly 3 degrees Celsius (5.4 degrees Fahrenheit) by 2050, even if all other countries meet targets agreed to under the Paris climate accord, according to a 2019 report from Tsinghua University’s Centre for Finance and Development, London-based Vivid Economics and the ClimateWorks Foundation in the United States.
The Chinese government has issued guidelines for green investments under the belt and road plan, but there are no legally binding restrictions on financing for coal or other fossil-fuel projects, said Christoph Nedopil Wang, founding director of the Green Belt and Road Initiative Centre in Beijing.
“Chinese overseas coal financing has been extremely demand-driven,” he said. “If they want coal, who are we to tell them not to fund coal? That is the current host country principle that China applies in overseas financing.”
Heavy carbon emitters in China’s belt and road network may put Paris climate targets at risk
The approach often puts China at odds with its positioning as a global leader in green finance and renewable development.
However, there are some promising signs: China’s development financing for coal has been in decline since 2017, and new data from the American Enterprise Institute showed that, for the first time, renewable energy investments in belt and road countries made up a greater share of overall energy investments than fossil fuels did in the first half of 2020.
Nedopil Wang, who also serves as an adviser to the Chinese government, including the commerce and environment ministries, said the recent shifts by Japan and South Korea would not have gone unnoticed in Beijing.
“I think there is a broad recognition in China that coal is not in line with the Paris Agreement, and so far China wants to adhere to the Paris Agreement,” he said. “China also wants the Belt and Road Initiative to be green.
“This understanding is increasing, but it is not going to change anything in the next year or two.”



Reporter’s notebook: Kazakhstan trip highlights promise and limits of Central Asia ties

Now Hong Kong must turn its international edge into national impact

Global monetary tightening tests China’s 2-speed economy

China’s crude imports are rising again. What will that mean for oil prices?

China economy

China slow to curb coal financing as Japan, South Korea ‘accept new reality’ on phasing out fossil fuels

China remains the primary global backer of coal power, and the nation’s overseas coal financing remains extremely demand-driven in the face of environmental concerns. Photo: AP

China remains the primary global backer of coal power, and the nation’s overseas coal financing remains extremely demand-driven in the face of environmental concerns. Photo: AFP

China’s coronavirus recovery drives boom in coal plants, casting doubt over commitments to cut fossil fuels

China has 249.6 gigawatts of coal-fired power capacity either under construction or in planning, according to Global Energy Monitor and the Centre for Research on Energy and Clean Air – which is larger than the current coal fleets of the United States or India. Photo: AP

China has 249.6 gigawatts of coal-fired power capacity either under construction or in planning, according to Global Energy Monitor and the Centre for Research on Energy and Clean Air – which is larger than the current coal fleets of the United States or India. Photo: Reuters

Howey Ou, China’s version of Greta Thunberg, pays price for climate activism

Howey Ou skipped classes for a week to protest about climate change in front of the local government office in Guilin last year. Photo: Twitter/Howey Ou

(FILES) In this file photo taken on March 6, 2020 Swedish environmentalist Greta Thunberg speaks during a "Youth Strike 4 Climate" protest march in Brussels. - Climate activist Greta Thunberg was on June 20 awarded a Portuguese rights award and promptly pledged the million-euro prize to groups working to protect the environment and halt climate change. (Photo by JOHN THYS / AFP)

Howey Ou, a 17-year-old mainland environmentalist.  Photo: Howey Ou Twitter

China’s plan to boost railway freight falls behind target, knocking air pollution battle off track

China wants to boost transport of bulk cargo by railway to cut air pollution. Photo: Shutterstock

China wants to boost transport of bulk cargo by railway to cut air pollution. Photo: Xinhua

China economy loses steam amid weak demand, coronavirus and floods, analysts say

China’s retail sales remain suppressed, shrinking by 1.1 per cent in July compared to a year earlier. Photo: AFP

Industrial production, a measurement of manufacturing and mining output in the world’s second largest economy, continued on its four-month growth streak following a contraction in the first quarter, expanding by 4.8 per cent in July from a year earlier, the same pace as June. Photo: Xinhua

Coronavirus: fears mount that China’s transition to a greener economy may be shelved amid recovery

US-based research firm Axios wrote last week that if ‘Beijing responds with a large property and construction-heavy stimulus package, the resulting increase in cement and steel production could increase carbon intensity.’ Photo: Getty Images

French Ecology Minister Segolene Royal (L), French President Francois Hollande (2ndL), French Foreign Minister Laurent Fabius (C) and United Nations Secretary General Ban Ki-moon (2ndR) applaud after a statement at the COP21 Climate Conference in Le Bourget, north of Paris, on December 12, 2015. The years-long quest for a universal pact to avert catastrophic climate change neared the finish line today with conference host France announcing that the final draft had been completed in the early hours of the morning. AFP PHOTO / MIGUEL MEDINA

US-based research firm Axios wrote last week that if “Beijing responds with a large property and construction-heavy stimulus package, the resulting increase in cement and steel production could increase carbon intensity.” Photo: Xinhua

Economy

Global Economy

China Economy

News

Asia

East Asia

Southeast Asia

China

Science

Diplomacy


Japan and South Korea recently made moves to limit financial backing for overseas coal projects, joining a trend of banks and multilateral lenders ditching the fossil fuel
As the largest global financier of coal energy, China is increasingly looking like the lender of last resort



As the primary global backer of coal power, China is likely to come under increasing pressure to scale back overseas coal investment following recent steps by South Korea and Japan to reduce state support.
