appConfigEntityId

bodyType

customContents

entityId

entityUuid

isVideo

articlePageQuery

article

articleSchemaContent

content

hooksArticlePageAdvertisementConfigArticle

hooksArticlePageFloatingButtonConfigArticle

appConfig

filter

json

liveArticle

Jane Cai

He Huifeng

Six months after losing his job at an online education firm amid an industry-wide crackdown, Michael Zhao now makes a living linking mainland students with foreign English tutors – albeit on the sly.
China banned classes with overseas tutors last summer and ordered private education companies to switch to non-profit status, part of an overhaul in the sector aimed at reining in runaway investment, easing students’ workloads and reducing financial pressure on families.
The clampdown on the private education industry, which had once employed more than 10 million people, has led to a flood of business closures and lay-offs around the nation.
“Now I’m self-employed,” said Zhao, who is using his English first name to protect his identity.
I understand at its core it is about fostering a bigger middle class. But ironically, I’m afraid I’ll fall out of the ranks before long
Michael Zhao
“So far the business is not bad. But I’m not sure if I’ll be able to sustain it because it is illegal.”
While working at his previous job as an assistant tutor, the 31 year old said he would spend his pay cheque each month with little thought, just like many of his middle-class friends. Now, he does not feel so confident.
“I’m considering leaving Beijing and selling my flat at loss,” said Zhao, a native of the eastern province of Shandong who studied sociology in Britain.
“Nowadays ‘common prosperity’ is a buzzword in state media. I understand at its core it is about fostering a bigger middle class. But ironically, I’m afraid I’ll fall out of the ranks before long.”
President Xi Jinping’s “common prosperity” goal, which aims to reduce China’s wealth gap, is now the nation’s main development objective.


The strategy is expected to feature prominently at the annual gathering of the nation’s top legislative and political consultative bodies in Beijing next month.
But China’s economy is slowing and facing a number of headwinds, from uncertainty caused by the coronavirus pandemic to geopolitical tensions. Coupled with the government’s heavy-handed push to reduce income inequality, some middle-class citizens are beginning to worry about their livelihoods.
About 400 million Chinese, or roughly 30 per cent of the population, are regarded as middle class – with an annual household income of between 100,000 yuan (US$15,800) and 500,000 yuan, according to the National Bureau of Statistics (NBS).
Beijing has vowed to enlarge the group, improve essential public services and narrow the nation’s income gap to a “reasonable range” by 2050.
‘Anxious’ Chinese rethink study-abroad options, from Canada to Malta and beyond
“China’s main approach has been limiting high incomes and raising low incomes. It’ll remain so amid the economic slowdown,” said Chen Daoyin, an independent political analyst and former professor at the Shanghai University of Political Science and Law.
As the economy slows, the middle class will be lucky to maintain a stable income because “common prosperity” mainly supports the poor, Chen said.
A survey by the People’s Bank of China at the end of last year showed that 37 per cent of respondents were finding it difficult to find employment, while only 13 per cent said job-seeking was easy. The other half said employment prospects were so-so.
Both the employment expectation index and income confidence index were at low levels, according to the survey of 20,000 saving account owners in 50 cities across the nation.
Beijing’s regulatory crackdown extended far beyond private tutoring, ensnaring the tech and gaming industries, as well as the property sector.


Lisa Zhou, who works for a leading telecommunications company in Shenzhen, said her employer was not affected by government action, but fell victim to a bearish sentiment in China’s stock market last year. Chinese stocks were among the world’s worst performers in 2021.
As a result, Zhou did not get a pay rise this year and the stock price of her company has fallen sharply, which might make her stock options valueless.
“My colleagues and I are all frustrated,” said Zhou. “Looking forward, while Shenzhen has a tax rebate policy for executives of technology companies, ordinary employees are not included. We’re very worried that the personal income tax burden will continue to grow soon with the expiration of some preferential policies.”
In January, China announced it would extend some personal income tax cuts until 2023 to help counter economic headwinds, including preferential tax policies on end-of-year bonuses and equity incentives at listed companies. These measures are expected to reduce taxes by 110 billion yuan a year, according to the State Council, China’s cabinet.
China’s population crisis could give women greater reproductive rights
In spite of the tax cuts, government revenue from personal income tax grew by 21 per cent last year from 2020, outpacing economic growth of 8.1 per cent. Middle income earners are the main contributors of personal income tax, which is 45 per cent in the highest bracket.
Although China’s high tax rates have been criticised by some economists for discouraging productivity, there is no sign they will be lowered soon.
Under common prosperity, China is focused on closing tax loopholes, and has punished celebrities for tax evasion, while encouraging the rich to make public donations.
George Magnus, a research associate at Oxford University’s China Centre, said: “I think there could certainly be some proposals to ease the tax burden on the middle class, and tighten it on ‘unreasonable’ incomes, but I doubt we are going to see a significant reform of the tax system.
The overriding goal this year is stability, and so I don’t expect any radical policy initiatives
George Magnus
“The overriding goal this year is stability, and so I don’t expect any radical policy initiatives.”
At the central economic work conference in December, China’s 25-member Politburo said that stability was key to economic decision-making in 2022.
Policymakers pledged to “front-load” policies to shore up the economy, which is facing threefold pressure, including contraction of demand, supply shocks and weaker expectations.
Zhou said many middle-class people in Shenzhen had heavy mortgages to pay and, with house prices falling, it puts a lot of “psychological pressure on people to cut daily spending”.
A weakening property market was one of reasons cited by the International Monetary Fund for slashing China’s 2022 economic growth forecast by 0.8 percentage points to 4.8 per cent in January.


The property sector, a key driver of economic growth, was hit by a slew of government curbs last year. The value of property sales grew by just 4.8 per cent to 18.2 trillion yuan (US$2.9 trillion) compared to 8.7 per cent growth in 2020.
The amount of floor space sold also grew by just 1.9 per cent last year, according to data from the NBS, with real estate investment growth falling to a 22-year low of 4.4 per cent last year.
As property prices tumble, some homeowners are choosing to suspend loan repayments.
A court in the city of Sanhe, fewer than two hours’ drive from downtown Beijing, has listed around 1,000 flats on e-commerce platform JD for auction since May 2020 after owners forfeited on repayments.
China’s local officials told don’t over-promise in common prosperity drive
Eli Ma, a 37-year-old marketing director at a Hong Kong-funded company in Guangzhou, worried the joint income he and his wife earned would not be enough to provide a so-called middle-class life for their 9-year-old son and their second child to be born in June.
“Both of our incomes are practically the same as in 2017 and 2018 as our business was impacted by the coronavirus pandemic,” he said.
“Home prices have soared and dropped like a roller coaster and now the property market is frozen and it is harder to sell than before.”
According to a central bank survey of more than 30,000 households in 2019, 70 per cent of the assets held by urban households, which make up most of China’s middle class, were in property.


“I feel quite upset that I’ve been working hard to get into the upper class, but now I feel like actually, I’m falling out of the middle class,” Ma said.
“With a monthly income of 30,000 yuan, most of it goes to pay the mortgages and the rest needs to support the daily expenses of four people.
“We’ve not been travelling for a long time, and we even have to stop paying the insurance we bought in Hong Kong a few years ago.
“I hope there’ll be policies to address my woes.”


Covid-19, climate change and conflict have left Asia-Pacific at a crossroads

Asia must close the pandemic education gap to tackle long-term wealth inequality

China urged to give cash handouts, as its economy and most vulnerable citizens are desperate for a lifeline

Philippine election ‘pink wave’, ‘brown face’ drama and more

Income inequality

China’s middle class worries about the future under Xi Jinping’s ‘common prosperity’ initiative

Reducing wealth inequality is now the main objective for China’s next stage of development. Photo: EPA-EFE

Reducing wealth inequality is now the main objective for China’s next stage of development. Photo: Bloomberg

China should tax the rich and raise the income threshold in common prosperity push: Gree Electric chief

Increasing the income tax threshold would help lift consumer spending, according to a prominent businesswoman. Photo: AP

China warns its local governments don’t be overambitious in carrying out ‘common prosperity’ drive

China’s rapid development over the past four decades has also deepened inequality, especially between urban and rural areas. Photo: AP

China’s rapid development over the past four decades has also deepened inequality, especially between urban and rural areas. Photo: AFP

China’s tax evaders to be ‘severely punished’ as Beijing pushes for ‘common prosperity’

Beijing wants a fairer tax system to help reach its goal of “common prosperity”. Photo: CWH

Beijing wants a fairer tax system to help reach its goal of “common prosperity”. Photo: Getty Images

China’s common prosperity push is accelerating, but how will life change in 10 years under Xi Jinping?

President Xi Jinping has been pushing for so-called common prosperity, which is aimed at narrowing the nation’s persistent wealth gap. Illustration: Craig Stephens

President Xi Jinping has been pushing for so-called common prosperity, which is aimed at narrowing the nation’s persistent wealth gap. Photo: Bloomberg

China’s top security official touts common prosperity campaign, points to ‘hidden peril’ of wealth gap

Common prosperity has become a central theme in President Xi Jinping’s economic policy in the past year. Photo: Xinhua

Guo Shengkun (left) said security organs should “focus on the promotion of common prosperity”, including by improving related laws and regulations. Photo: AFP

Economy

China Economy

News

China

Money & Wealth

Knowledge

China Macro Economy

Social Policy


President Xi Jinping’s strategy to reduce wealth inequality is now the main objective in China’s next stage of development
But heavy-handed regulation coupled with a slowing economy has some middle-class citizens worried about their livelihoods



President Xi Jinping’s goal to reduce wealth inequality is front and centre on the government agenda, but heavy-handed regulation and a slowing economy has some middle-class Chinese worried about their future.


China economy

Xi Jinping

China jobs

China society