Advertisement

Opinion | Preserving Fanling golf course or building public housing is not a binary choice

  • Supporting more public housing does not mean we have to bulldoze what the elite have built, just as advocating for the golf course does not mean we are ignoring those in need
  • Officials should be looking for creative alternatives and realise that stepping back from a former administration’s proposal would show how we have evolved

Reading Time:4 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
5
Golfers play on the Old Course at Fanling on June 13. The Hong Kong Golf Club’s Fanling course is set to lose 32 hectares of land, including nine hectares earmarked for public housing. Photo: Elson Li

I do not play golf and have not even taken a swing at a driving range. I have made golf jokes about how I did not want to spend my time hitting a small ball into a small hole very far away, or how golf commentators are always soft-spoken as they do not want to wake the television audience.

Advertisement
However, real knowledge is knowing the extent of one’s ignorance. Golf must be a great sport, given that so many people embrace it, and a great place to conduct business, with so many deals struck on the course – never mind the US$10 billion global market for golf clubs alone.

Architects and designers always have to learn new things, sometimes on a very steep learning curve, going from amateur to semi-expert in a short time. That was what happened to me when I had to design a golf course in my third and final year of graduate school. I learned about birdies and bogeys, fairways and the rough, as well as player handicaps.

Golf course design is a science even though it may not appear so, possibly because of the manicured grass and connection to nature. An 18-hole course needs to provide a variety of challenges, including each hole’s playing length, terrain, altitude and surrounding obstacles. Lose any of the holes and the course is ruined.

A truly great course with an appropriate legacy carries its value because of the full experience it offers. This is what attracts the Aramco Team Series, the World City Championship or any international golf tournament. This is the beckoning of “Hello Hong Kong”.
Advertisement
Hong Kong Golf Club general committee captain Andy Kwok Wing-leung has emphasised that keeping the three 18-hole courses at Fanling is critical in hosting reputable tournaments and bringing in the LIV Golf tour.
Advertisement