Advertisement
Ukraine war
Opinion
Karsten Neuhoff
Isabella M. Weber
Karsten NeuhoffandIsabella M. Weber

The View | Can Europe survive looming gas shortages as Russia halts supplies?

  • While the EU debates whether it can survive Russia halting gas supplies and at what cost, less has been said about preparing for shortages
  • Higher prices will not be sufficient and rationing should be a last resort, so governments must come up with initiatives that draw popular support

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
11
Surplus gas burns off at the PCK Petroleum Refinery in Schwedt, Germany, on Monday. Russia’s decision to cut off gas deliveries to Poland and Bulgaria has heightened the urgency for EU countries to find new supplies while also greatly reducing their gas use. Photo: DPA
What would a stop on Russian gas imports mean for European economies? The question sharply divides economists. Everyone agrees there would be negative consequences, but how bad? Predictions range from a mild recession to economic disaster and mass unemployment.

Yet for all the intellectual energy that has been expended estimating the magnitude of potential GDP contractions, much less has been said about how to prepare for gas shortages if Russia takes it upon itself to close the taps. It is analogous to forecasting the extent of damage a hurricane will cause instead of actually preparing for the storm.

But now that Russia has suspended gas deliveries to Poland and Bulgaria, European policymakers and pundits have no choice. They must shift the focus from probable outcomes, which no one can predict with precision, to containing the consequences of potential gas shortages.
Advertisement

All of Europe’s gas providers – not just European Union producers but also neighbouring countries delivering gas by pipeline and exporters of global liquefied natural gas – are already operating at full capacity.

Gas delivered mostly by pipeline from Russia constitutes around 40 per cent of EU supply. Should this supply be interrupted, as it could well be, EU gas consumption would have to be reduced significantly.

02:51

Putin tells ‘unfriendly’ nations to pay in roubles for Russian gas as economic sanctions bite

Putin tells ‘unfriendly’ nations to pay in roubles for Russian gas as economic sanctions bite

In principle, three mechanisms can facilitate this reduced consumption: high prices, government programmes and mandatory rationing. In our view, the price mechanism alone will not be sufficient to manage shortages. Gas prices are already at record levels in Europe, and gas saving is far from sufficient.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x