Advertisement
Taiwan
Opinion
J. Stapleton Roy

Opinion | US should not encourage Taiwan to court destruction

  • The vibrant democracy in Taiwan is a global success story, but thumbing its nose at China and hoping the US will deal with the consequences is not the way to go
  • However, the US Congress lacks the courage to tell Taiwan to avoid pushing red lines, even when this is of critical importance to preserving democracy on the island

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
9
US Representative Mark Takano chats with Taiwanese President Tsai Ing-wen at the Presidential Office in Taipei on November 26. Five US lawmakers met with Tsai in a surprise one-day visit intended to reaffirm the United States’ “rock solid” support for the self-governing island. Photo: Taiwan Presidential Office via AP
As the democracies of the world assemble to celebrate their forms of governance, they would be wise to reflect on some of the deficiencies of democracy along with its successes.

Properly functioning democracy is the only truly modern form of governance. The just powers of governance, in other words the legitimacy of democratic systems, rest on elections that reflect the will of the people, and such systems rely on checks and balances to prevent the concentration of power that leads to tyranny.

These core features permit enormous diversity in the particular forms of democracy, with each form taking on national characteristics. However, democracies contain the seeds of their own destruction. They are dependent on the middle classes for their vitality, they cannot function without compromise, they are vulnerable to popular passions and demagogues, and they are capable of precipitating wars.

Advertisement

Democracies cannot function in polarised societies. We have experienced this once before. The result was a bloody civil war. Because of these deficiencies, democracies have a significant mortality rate.

Nazi leader Adolf Hitler (left) and his deputy Rudolf Hess. The weaknesses of European democracies in addressing the rising threat of conflict permitted Hitler to run roughshod over the continent. Photo: AP
Nazi leader Adolf Hitler (left) and his deputy Rudolf Hess. The weaknesses of European democracies in addressing the rising threat of conflict permitted Hitler to run roughshod over the continent. Photo: AP
The democracies that emerged in Europe after World War I could not manage the contradictions between nationalism and self-determination created by the checkerboard distribution of minority ethnic groups in central Europe. They were replaced by authoritarian alternatives.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x