Advertisement

Opinion | Has China learned its lesson from the coronavirus tragedy? Judging by its continued censorship, no

  • Official responses following Li Wenliang’s death show little sign Beijing realises that the muzzling of information has life-and-death consequences for the world. An unrepentant China may leave the world no choice but to decouple

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
A man wearing a mask walks past a mural showing a modified image of the Communist Party emblem in Shanghai. Photo: Reuters

The Covid-19 pandemic is taking a heavy toll, with more than 9,000 people dead, including over 3,200 in China alone. But has China learned its lessons from the tragedy, to put its people’s lives before anything else and regain the world’s trust?

Advertisement
Given what happened to the whistle-blower-turned-national-hero Dr Li Wenliang, my answer is no. Li – one of eight doctors who attempted to alert the public about the coronavirus outbreak, only to be reprimanded by local police – died on February 7.
Li’s death triggered huge waves of demand for freedom of speech across Chinese society and Beijing, on the day of his death, took the unusual move of sending an investigation team to Wuhan to look into “issues of public concern relating to Li Wenliang”. Yet, six weeks passed before any results were released to the public.
Second, Xinhua reporter Liao Jun took to the stage in Wuhan at a press conference organised by China’s State Council on March 8, and was hailed a “hero” for her frontline coverage of the coronavirus outbreak. But it was Liao who wrote a series of stories alleging that Li and other whistle-blowers were spreading rumours, and dismissing the risk of human-to-human transmission in the early days of the epidemic.
Xinhua reporter Liao Jun interviews a person outside Wuchang Hospital on February 18. Photo: Xinhua
Xinhua reporter Liao Jun interviews a person outside Wuchang Hospital on February 18. Photo: Xinhua
Advertisement

This absurdity sparked an online backlash against Liao and Beijing, only to be deleted and blocked by internet censors.

Advertisement