Advertisement

Opinion | Theresa May and the EU can’t resolve Brexit without more time, and then a second referendum

  • Alan Rosling says it’s not clear how any Brexit deal could clear Parliament – and the European Union – before the present deadline, and political divisions are too deep to resolve without another vote

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Brexit opponent Steve Bray demonstrates opposite the Houses of Parliament in London on January 21. Photo: AP
This week, UK Prime Minister Theresa May returned to the House of Commons with her Plan B for Brexit. Last week, on January 15, she suffered an unprecedented and massive defeat in Parliament on the proposed deal with the European Union. The fact that her revised plan was little changed from her original deal shows the profound crisis of leadership and political imagination in the UK. There seems no realistic prospect of negotiating sufficient changes to the deal to achieve agreement in time for the UK to leave the EU on schedule on March 29. 
Advertisement

The UK has been pitched into the worst political and constitutional crisis in living memory. Former prime minister David Cameron’s decision to call a referendum over the UK’s membership in the EU was designed to contain deep splits in the Conservative Party over Europe. Instead, the unexpected victory of the Leave campaign triggered the slide towards the current toxic impasse.

May’s handling of the negotiations with Europe and her decision to call an election in 2017, resulting in the loss of her majority in the House of Commons, have pushed the country towards a train-wreck Brexit. The opposition Labour Party, led by Jeremy Corbyn, contributed to the loss of the referendum. Corbyn has subsequently provided no constructive alternative proposals to those cobbled together by the prime minister. There appears to be no majority for any feasible outcome in a deeply divided Commons; party discipline has melted away and leadership is absent.

The default position is that the UK will exit the EU, with or without agreed terms, on March 29, in just over two months’ time. While there are a few convinced Brexiteers who believe leaving the EU without a deal is an acceptable risk, the vast majority of politicians, economists and business leaders think that a so-called hard Brexit would inflict serious damage to the country. The worst-case scenarios suggest there would be significant disruption to trade, travel and supplies of essential items. The Bank of England has modelled downside scenarios that envisage GDP shrinking by as much as 8 per cent with nasty knock-on effects on employment, inflation, asset prices and the pound.

The only thing on which most MPs can agree is that crashing out of the EU without a deal is unacceptable. Yet, in the absence of another solution agreed upon not just by the UK Parliament but also the 27 remaining members of EU, the UK seems set to fall out of the EU in just a few weeks.

May still appears to believe she can bounce the EU into relaxing the terms on the Irish backstop in her agreed deal. This, she hopes, would engender enough support from her own revolting backbenchers, the Democratic Unionist Party of Northern Ireland (on whom her minority government depends) and some moderate Labour MPs to pass the revised exit deal. However, the EU has given her very little comfort that they would concede legally binding changes to the backstop.
Advertisement