Advertisement

The View | As Australia and the UK show, banker-bashing is all well and good, but directors need to be brought to book

Richard Harris says inquiries in Australia and the UK reveal that bad behaviour by banks is rife, but the solution may be to hold senior management accountable rather than delegating to overzealous compliance departments

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Passers-by are reflected in the glass door of a National Australia Bank branch in Sydney in October 2010. A royal commission is looking into allegations that Australian banks have engaged in several malpractices, such as bribery, forged documents and denial of responsible lending obligations. Photo: AFP
Politicians usually try to kick tricky problems into the long grass by having a commission of inquiry or a public consultation that we all know is intended to bury the issue until the next one comes along.
Advertisement

Having just been to Australia, I have been following the quaintly named royal commission on the behaviour of banks. Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull fought hard against it – a royal commission is much harder to kick. Banking is a naturally adversarial practice and conflicts of interest abound, so it is unsurprising that the commission has uncovered banking practices ranging from the merely unpleasant to borderline criminal. Regardless of the merits, newspaper editors have been in headline heaven with banker bashing.

Banks have behaved badly with allegations before the commission including bribery, forged documents, failure to verify customers’ ability to pay back before lending them money, fraudulent documentation, denying processing or administration errors, price manipulation, breaches of responsible lending obligations and money-laundering laws, mis-selling insurance to people who can’t afford it, lying to regulators and charging fees to dead clients.

Women walk by a Westpac sign in Melbourne in May 2009. Westpac is one of Australia’s four big banks investigated under the royal commission. Photo: AFP
Women walk by a Westpac sign in Melbourne in May 2009. Westpac is one of Australia’s four big banks investigated under the royal commission. Photo: AFP
Advertisement
Advertisement