Advertisement
Legacy of war in Asia
Opinion

Was Ho Chi Minh the reason why the Vietnam War is history, but the wounds of Korea still fester?

John Barry Kotch says what sets apart the Korean War from the later conflict in Vietnam is the lack of a unified political elite amid the Soviet-US divide, especially the absence of a clear national leader like Ho Chi Minh

3-MIN READ3-MIN
North Korean leader Kim Jong-un leads a memorial ceremony at the Fatherland Liberation War Martyrs Cemetery in Pyongyang on July 27, the 64th anniversary of the Korean War armistice agreement. Photo: AFP/KCNA via KNS
John Barry Kotch

While the first world war ended with a punitive peace, complete with harsh reparations and prolonged occupation, setting the stage for the second world war, the latter was the opposite, ending with a relatively benign occupation of the two main Axis powers (Germany and Japan), a peace treaty, and their subsequent reintegration into the community of nations.

By contrast, post-second world war conflicts in global hotspots such as Korea, Vietnam, Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya and Syria have experienced less favourable outcomes. Apart from Iraq, they have all been intra-state or civil wars in which outside powers have generally been unable to impose their will and – with the sole exception of the 1991 Gulf War and Vietnam – remain unresolved.

Korea and Vietnam, both brush-fire wars on China’s periphery, are studies in contrast. Why is there closure in Vietnam four decades after the fighting ended, while there is none in Korea six decades later, making it the living symbol of the unfinished business of the cold war and currently threatening a regional nuclear conflagration?
Commuters at a railway station in Seoul watch a TV news broadcast about North Korea’s test launch of an intercontinental ballistic missile, on July 4. Photo: AFP
Commuters at a railway station in Seoul watch a TV news broadcast about North Korea’s test launch of an intercontinental ballistic missile, on July 4. Photo: AFP
Select Voice
Select Speed
1x
AI-generated voice