appConfigEntityId

bodyType

customContents

entityId

entityUuid

isVideo

articlePageQuery

article

articleSchemaContent

content

hooksArticlePageAdvertisementConfigArticle

hooksArticlePageFloatingButtonConfigArticle

appConfig

filter

json

liveArticle

Ian Young

“You’ll delete my number won’t you? After we hang up, you’ll delete that, right?” said the protester, who asked that I identify her only as “Jessica”.
Jessica lives in Vancouver, where she attends protests about Hong Kong – waving the same black flag that resulted this month in the first charge of inciting secession under new national security laws in her former home city.
The charge carries a maximum penalty of life imprisonment.
“Liberate Hong Kong; Revolution of Our Times,” the allegedly secessionist flag proclaims.
There is ‘white terror’ going on right now, in the whole community. The CCP influence has deeply penetrated Canadian society
Vancouver protester ‘Jessica’
For the past year, such flags have been a feature of Hong Kong-related protests in Vancouver, home to a large diaspora population. But the introduction of Hong Kong’s new national security laws on July 1 has raised the stakes for flag-waving protesters who now weigh the risks of prosecution should they ever return to the city.
Another Vancouver protester, asking to be called “Wah”, waves a different banner of the Hong Kong democracy movement, the black bauhinia flag that is based on the official red-and-white flag of the territory.
He too fears arrest should he return to Hong Kong to see his mother, in her 90s and suffering from late-stage Alzheimer’s disease.
The activist’s family worries about him so much that he no longer tells them when he protests. He wears a mask, sunglasses and a hat to conceal his identity.

Albert Chan Wai-yip, a former pro-democracy legislator in Hong Kong who retired to Vancouver about three years ago, has been waving black protest flags for a decade.
Unlike Wah and Jessica, Chan doesn’t worry about being identified while waving his black bauhinia outside the Chinese consulate general and at other protests in Vancouver. That’s because he has no plans to return to Hong Kong.
“I would be arrested there. I am certain of that,” he said.
The security laws – which were imposed by Beijing without a Hong Kong consultation process – criminalise acts or incitement of secession, subversion, terrorism and collusion with foreign powers in Hong Kong. But they also criminalise such behaviour anywhere else in the world, regardless of whether the alleged offender is a resident of Hong Kong.
Protest banners and slogans advocating Hong Kong independence now illegal
That provision is foremost in the minds of some protesters in Vancouver, particularly in light of the approach taken by police in Hong Kong, where protesters have been arrested under the new laws for showing material with what the force called Hong Kong independence “slogans”.
Those included stickers bearing the word “conscience”, and “Resist Beijing Liberate Hong Kong”, as well as caricatures of Chinese President Xi Jinping made to resemble the coronavirus.
In a late-night briefing on the eve of the law coming into force, police had been told by the Hong Kong Department of Justice that flags and banners calling for independence, liberation or revolution would be illegal.

The four crimes covered by the security law all carry maximum life sentences, although the suggested sentence for some minor offences is up to three years in jail.
The first person charged under the laws was Tong Ying-kit, who allegedly rode his motorcycle into a group of police on July 1 while flying the “Liberate Hong Kong” black flag. He has been charged with terrorism and inciting secession.
Jessica, who moved from Hong Kong to Vancouver in the 1980s but declined to give her age, was waving the same black flag outside the Chinese consulate in Vancouver on July 1.
Ex-diplomats press Congress to help Hongkongers gain asylum in US
Hundreds took part in that rally, marching up Granville Street in heavy rain to shout slogans and listen to speeches outside the diplomatic compound, where a security camera hangs over the wall and swivels back and forth during such protests.
Her nervousness discussing her activities in a phone interview was palpable. She confirmed her identity as a black-flag waver by taking a photo of her flag, arranged in a certain way that was agreed with the South China Morning Post. The picture was then forwarded to a second person, who took a screenshot of the picture before forwarding it to the Post.
Jessica said she never waves the black flag without wearing a face mask. Nor does she share pictures of herself holding the flag on social media, although she is otherwise vocal about her political views.

Three females were arrested respectively for showing materials with #HKIndependence slogans in #CausewayBay, violating #NSL. Anyone who organises, plans, commits or participates in committing secession or undermining national unification shall be guilty of an offence. pic.twitter.com/SB3vYQyiha
— Hong Kong Police Force (@hkpoliceforce) July 1, 2020

Asked why she was so cautious, she sighed and said “China is not behaving like a normal country”.
Jessica said she bought her “Liberate Hong Kong, Revolution of Our Times” flag on Amazon.
What does the slogan mean to her?
“I want Hong Kong to be what it was supposed to be, under the idea of ‘one country, two systems’,” she said. She called the idea of Hong Kong independence an “invention” by the former Hong Kong chief executive Leung Chun-ying and Beijing, originally intended to demonise the Hong Kong “umbrella movement” pro-democracy protests in 2014.
US-China decoupling already under way, John Bolton says
“Before that, no one even talked about it [independence] … No one used to need to wave this kind of flag. It’s just that China and CY Leung created this situation,” she said. “If Hong Kong was more normal like before there would be no need. Now it’s not normal.”
But Jessica said she now supported Hong Kong independence “as an option” for the city.
She said that she would continue to wave the black flag, but that the protest movement in Vancouver was changing: “There is ‘white terror’ going on right now, in the whole community,” she said, alluding to suppression of political dissent. “The CCP influence has deeply penetrated Canadian society.”

Jessica said she travelled regularly to Hong Kong and planned to do so after the pandemic.
But she worried she had already been identified by authorities. “I wear a mask but besides the flag, I do express myself about the situation in Hong Kong. I’m a Canadian, so I don’t think that’s a problem. But the flag – that is probably a problem, so I do not put it up [on social media].”
Jessica said she had family in Hong Kong, but they did not know she waved the black flag. “I don’t tell them. They’d just worry about me.”
‘Now it feels like the CCP is winning’
Wah, a veteran of Hong Kong’s protest movements who is now nearing retirement age, has been keeping secrets from his family too.
He has been waving the black bauhinia at protests across Metro Vancouver, including recent rallies in Richmond and outside the Vancouver Art Gallery.
“I always carry the flag with me in my car,” he said with a grim laugh. “Just in case. It’s my icon.”
He said the black flag meant that Hong Kong was undergoing a “dark age”: “Things have been inverted. Democracy has gone dark. Life is twisted.”
[My family] worry about me getting arrested in Hong Kong, or even harassed here in Vancouver. They go against my appearing at the rallies. So now I just don’t tell them
Vancouver protester ‘Wah’
Interviewed by phone, he confirmed his identity by sending a photo of himself with the flag; he was masked and wore sunglasses, but was in a setting prearranged with the Post. 
Wah moved to Vancouver in 1993, and before the pandemic he was a frequent traveller back to Hong Kong, where relatives including his ailing mother still live. He attended protests in Hong Kong too, and gave speeches.
Now his wife and children in Vancouver worry that his identity will be exposed.
“But I feel these things from the bottom of my heart. Some people cannot do these things, but I can do them … so how can I not?” said Wah, his voice cracking before he suppressed the emotion with another chuckle.
“They worry about me getting arrested in Hong Kong, or even harassed here in Vancouver. They go against my appearing at the rallies. So now I just don’t tell them.” He paused, then laughed again.
He didn’t used to be so careful about protecting his identity. Wah recalled protesting outside the Vancouver consulate – unmasked – in 2013, when he said men emerged from the compound and started videoing the protesters’ faces and following them. He also suspected his phone calls had been monitored.

“Back then, I was aggressive. But now it feels like the CCP is winning. They have so many people around us,” he said.
He wanted to return to Hong Kong to care for his mother, who is in what he called the terminal stage of Alzheimer’s.
“But I was advised by many peers not to go. I plan to go but I might be caught, I don’t know what will happen …” he said, his voice trailing off.
Trump signs Hong Kong Autonomy Act, and ends city’s special trade status
He said he still hadn’t decided whether to take the risk.
Wah said he rested his hopes for the Hong Kong protest movement on international pressure convincing Beijing to change its approach to the city.
He struggled to define his emotions when he waved the black flag. It didn’t feel criminal, he said.
“I don’t know. Maybe I inspire people. Most times, I cannot hold back my tears. I wave the flag, I sing the song. I cry,” he said, referring to the protest anthem, Glory to Hong Kong.
‘I’d definitely be one of the people targeted’
Albert Chan, 65, has not been back to Hong Kong since exiting the fractious political arena there and opting for a quieter life in Vancouver, where the former legislator plays ping-pong and spends time with his granddaughters.
But he is still a protester, easily identifiable at pro-democracy rallies with his burly frame as he waves a black bauhinia flag.
“The law is a catastrophic situation for so many Hongkongers [in Vancouver] who spoke out about China,” said Chan by phone. “I don’t think they will be going back to Hong Kong at this time.”

Chan said he was the first person in Hong Kong to use the black bauhinia flag, which he said he and a designer friend devised about 10 years ago. It replaces the red background of the official Hong Kong flag with black; other, more recent versions show the central white bauhinia flower withering or dripping blood.
“This indicates that Hong Kong democracy is in a dark age … at that time we were the most radical group in Hong Kong. I was being pepper-sprayed back in 2011, arrested numerous times in those years,” said Chan, who was a legislator in Hong Kong for a total of 22 years between 1991 and 2016.
Chan said he also cheered the message of the “Liberate Hong Kong” flag.
It’s sad. For myself, that I can’t go back with my daughter, my granddaughter, to see this place? Hong Kong is a lovely place. We have so many memories
Former Hong Kong legislator Albert Chan Wai-yip
“It means we won’t give up, we will continue to fight for universal suffrage. We want changes. Simple reforms are not enough. We want a holistic change of the system. Take out all the functional constituencies,” he said, referring to the profession and interest-based electorates that choose 30 of Hong Kong’s 70 legislative seats.
“One person, one vote for chief executive. We don’t want China to manipulate and control Hong Kong.”
And as for the concept of “one country, two systems”?
“Well, if there is genuine ‘one country two systems’, we can accept that. I accept the social contract concept, agreed upon in 1984, the Sino-British Joint Agreement. But if China is violating that agreement? Then Hong Kong people have the right to overthrow the Chinese government.”

It is a sentiment that risks an accusation of subversion under Article 22 of the new security law, which bans actions with a view to “overthrowing the body of central power of the People’s Republic of China”.
Chan said the provision that covered alleged offences committed outside Hong Kong was intended to frighten overseas Hongkongers out of protesting. And it was working to some extent, he said; some protesters were “becoming more discreet”.
As for Chan, he said he would keep protesting, although he doubted he would ever be able to show his face in Hong Kong any time soon.
 
“It’s sad. For myself, that I can’t go back with my daughter, my granddaughter, to see this place? Hong Kong is a lovely place. We have so many memories. It’s a tragic situation,” he said.
The Chinese embassy in Ottawa did not respond to a request for comment on this article.

The Hongcouver blog is devoted to the hybrid culture of its namesake cities: Hong Kong and Vancouver. All story ideas and comments are welcome. Connect with me by email ian.young@scmp.com or on Twitter, @ianjamesyoung70.


Hong Kong hits out at US panel over Jimmy Lai hearing and sanctions bill

Hong Kong 999 callers can send real-time audio, video data from 2028: Chris Tang

Beijing’s ‘trust issue’ with Hong Kong and what the city can promise in its 5-year plan

No ‘red line’ for approving assemblies but security threats remain: police chief

Hong Kong national security law (NSL)

Fear of Hong Kong security law spreads in Vancouver, but some dare wave the black flags of ‘revolution’

Unidentified protesters carry “Liberate Hong Kong” flags on a march towards the Chinese consulate-general in Vancouver on July 1. Photo: Albert Chan Wai-yip

A protester holding up a black HKSAR flag while protesters march against the extradition bill outside the Legislative Council Complex in Tamar on the 22nd anniversary of Hong Kong's handover from Britain to China. 01JUL19 SCMP / Winson Wong

A motorcyclist carries a "Liberate Hong Kong" flag in Causeway Bay, Hong Kong, before being arrested on July 1. Photo: Cable TV

Former Hong Kong legislator Albert Chan Wai-yip (right) with a fellow protester at a rally outside the Chinese consulate-general in Vancouver on July 1. Photo: Handout / Albert Chan Wai-yip

Albert Chan Wai-yip waves a black bauhinia flag at a protest in Richmond, British Columbia, in October 2019. Photo: Ian Young

An unidentified protester holds up a “Liberate Hong Kong” flag at a rally outside the Chinese consulate-general in Vancouver on July 1. Photo: Albert Chan Wai-yip

National security law: former diplomats press Congress to help Hongkongers gain asylum in the US

A man outside the offices of the US Consulate General to Hong Kong on July 4 displays a US flag as part of a protest against Hong Kong’s new national security law. Photo: EPA-EFE

Kurt Tong, former US consul general to Hong Kong, in New York on Tuesday, Dec. 10. Photo: SCMP

US-China decoupling is already happening, says Donald Trump’s former security chief John Bolton, also calling for open borders for Hongkongers

Donald Trump’s national security adviser John Bolton in September 2019. Photo: AP

TOPSHOT - This illustration photo taken on June 23, 2020 in Glendale, California, shows John Bolton's book "The Room Where it Happened" on the day of it's release in Los Angeles. - The Trump administration tried unsuccessfully to block publication of Bolton's book claiming it contained classified national security information.Former US national security advisor John Bolton said Sunday he thinks North Korean leader Kim Jong Un "gets a huge laugh" over US counterpart Donald Trump's perception of their relationship. Bolton spoke to ABC News for his first interview ahead of the Tuesday release of his tell-all book, which contains many damning allegations against Trump. (Photo by Chris DELMAS / AFP)

epa08212941 Uyghur minority people walk on the Guangzhou main railway station wearing protective masks for protection of Covid-19 in Guangzhou, China, 12 February 2020. The disease caused by the novel coronavirus (SARS-CoV-2) has been officially named Covid-19 by the World Health Organization (WHO). The outbreak, which originated in the Chinese city of Wuhan, has so far killed at least 1,115 people and infected over 45,000 others worldwide, mostly in China. EPA-EFE/ALEX PLAVEVSKI

US National Security Adviser John Bolton with President Donald Trump in May 2019. Photo: AFP

US President Donald Trump signs Hong Kong Autonomy Act, and ends the city’s preferential trade status

US President Donald Trump arriving at the news conference Tuesday in the Rose Garden at the White House, at which he announced new measures against China over its actions against Hong Kong. Photo: Reuters

epa08526159 A man displays a US flag to celebrate 04 July Independence Day outside the US Consulate General in Hong Kong, China, 04 July 2020. On 02 July the US Senate gave its final approval to the Hong Kong Autonomy Act requiring mandatory sanctions against foreign individuals and banks over the erosion of Hong Kong autonomy. EPA-EFE/JEROME FAVRE

Hong Kong security law: flags, banners and slogans advocating independence, liberation or revolution now illegal

Protesters mark the one-year anniversary of the anti-government movement on June 12, 2020. Photo: Dickson Lee

Police's a new warning flag against behaviour with an intent of secession or subversion which warrants up to life imprisonment.  Photo: Handout

Opinion

Blogs


Canadian protesters worry they will be arrested if they return to Hong Kong, after waving the ‘Liberate Hong Kong’ banner or the black bauhinia flag
Some go to great lengths to conceal their identities from authorities and keep their activities secret from family members



Canadian protesters worry they will be arrested if they return to Hong Kong. Some go to great lengths to conceal their identities from authorities and keep their activities secret from family members.


Hongcouver

Hong Kong politics

Hong Kong police

Vancouver

Canada

Chinese overseas

Human rights

Human rights in China

Censorship in China

Censorship

Expresses the views, ideas and conclusions of the author. (Eg. Enough of Crazy Rich Asians, think of crazy poor Hongkongers.)


Column

The Hongcouver